xref: /openbsd/gnu/usr.bin/perl/pod/perlport.pod (revision e0680481)
1=head1 NAME
2
3perlport - Writing portable Perl
4
5=head1 DESCRIPTION
6
7Perl runs on numerous operating systems.  While most of them share
8much in common, they also have their own unique features.
9
10This document is meant to help you to find out what constitutes portable
11Perl code.  That way once you make a decision to write portably,
12you know where the lines are drawn, and you can stay within them.
13
14There is a tradeoff between taking full advantage of one particular
15type of computer and taking advantage of a full range of them.
16Naturally, as you broaden your range and become more diverse, the
17common factors drop, and you are left with an increasingly smaller
18area of common ground in which you can operate to accomplish a
19particular task.  Thus, when you begin attacking a problem, it is
20important to consider under which part of the tradeoff curve you
21want to operate.  Specifically, you must decide whether it is
22important that the task that you are coding has the full generality
23of being portable, or whether to just get the job done right now.
24This is the hardest choice to be made.  The rest is easy, because
25Perl provides many choices, whichever way you want to approach your
26problem.
27
28Looking at it another way, writing portable code is usually about
29willfully limiting your available choices.  Naturally, it takes
30discipline and sacrifice to do that.  The product of portability
31and convenience may be a constant.  You have been warned.
32
33Be aware of two important points:
34
35=over 4
36
37=item Not all Perl programs have to be portable
38
39There is no reason you should not use Perl as a language to glue Unix
40tools together, or to prototype a Macintosh application, or to manage the
41Windows registry.  If it makes no sense to aim for portability for one
42reason or another in a given program, then don't bother.
43
44=item Nearly all of Perl already I<is> portable
45
46Don't be fooled into thinking that it is hard to create portable Perl
47code.  It isn't.  Perl tries its level-best to bridge the gaps between
48what's available on different platforms, and all the means available to
49use those features.  Thus almost all Perl code runs on any machine
50without modification.  But there are some significant issues in
51writing portable code, and this document is entirely about those issues.
52
53=back
54
55Here's the general rule: When you approach a task commonly done
56using a whole range of platforms, think about writing portable
57code.  That way, you don't sacrifice much by way of the implementation
58choices you can avail yourself of, and at the same time you can give
59your users lots of platform choices.  On the other hand, when you have to
60take advantage of some unique feature of a particular platform, as is
61often the case with systems programming (whether for Unix, Windows,
62VMS, etc.), consider writing platform-specific code.
63
64When the code will run on only two or three operating systems, you
65may need to consider only the differences of those particular systems.
66The important thing is to decide where the code will run and to be
67deliberate in your decision.
68
69The material below is separated into three main sections: main issues of
70portability (L</"ISSUES">), platform-specific issues (L</"PLATFORMS">), and
71built-in Perl functions that behave differently on various ports
72(L</"FUNCTION IMPLEMENTATIONS">).
73
74This information should not be considered complete; it includes possibly
75transient information about idiosyncrasies of some of the ports, almost
76all of which are in a state of constant evolution.  Thus, this material
77should be considered a perpetual work in progress
78(C<< <IMG SRC="yellow_sign.gif" ALT="Under Construction"> >>).
79
80=head1 ISSUES
81
82=head2 Newlines
83
84In most operating systems, lines in files are terminated by newlines.
85Just what is used as a newline may vary from OS to OS.  Unix
86traditionally uses C<\012>, one type of DOSish I/O uses C<\015\012>,
87S<Mac OS> uses C<\015>, and z/OS uses C<\025>.
88
89Perl uses C<\n> to represent the "logical" newline, where what is
90logical may depend on the platform in use.  In MacPerl, C<\n> always
91means C<\015>.  On EBCDIC platforms, C<\n> could be C<\025> or C<\045>.
92In DOSish perls, C<\n> usually means C<\012>, but when
93accessing a file in "text" mode, perl uses the C<:crlf> layer that
94translates it to (or from) C<\015\012>, depending on whether you're
95reading or writing. Unix does the same thing on ttys in canonical
96mode.  C<\015\012> is commonly referred to as CRLF.
97
98To trim trailing newlines from text lines use
99L<C<chomp>|perlfunc/chomp VARIABLE>.  With default settings that function
100looks for a trailing C<\n> character and thus trims in a portable way.
101
102When dealing with binary files (or text files in binary mode) be sure
103to explicitly set L<C<$E<sol>>|perlvar/$E<sol>> to the appropriate value for
104your file format before using L<C<chomp>|perlfunc/chomp VARIABLE>.
105
106Because of the "text" mode translation, DOSish perls have limitations in
107using L<C<seek>|perlfunc/seek FILEHANDLE,POSITION,WHENCE> and
108L<C<tell>|perlfunc/tell FILEHANDLE> on a file accessed in "text" mode.
109Stick to L<C<seek>|perlfunc/seek FILEHANDLE,POSITION,WHENCE>-ing to
110locations you got from L<C<tell>|perlfunc/tell FILEHANDLE> (and no
111others), and you are usually free to use
112L<C<seek>|perlfunc/seek FILEHANDLE,POSITION,WHENCE> and
113L<C<tell>|perlfunc/tell FILEHANDLE> even in "text" mode.  Using
114L<C<seek>|perlfunc/seek FILEHANDLE,POSITION,WHENCE> or
115L<C<tell>|perlfunc/tell FILEHANDLE> or other file operations may be
116non-portable.  If you use L<C<binmode>|perlfunc/binmode FILEHANDLE> on a
117file, however, you can usually
118L<C<seek>|perlfunc/seek FILEHANDLE,POSITION,WHENCE> and
119L<C<tell>|perlfunc/tell FILEHANDLE> with arbitrary values safely.
120
121A common misconception in socket programming is that S<C<\n eq \012>>
122everywhere.  When using protocols such as common Internet protocols,
123C<\012> and C<\015> are called for specifically, and the values of
124the logical C<\n> and C<\r> (carriage return) are not reliable.
125
126    print $socket "Hi there, client!\r\n";      # WRONG
127    print $socket "Hi there, client!\015\012";  # RIGHT
128
129However, using C<\015\012> (or C<\cM\cJ>, or C<\x0D\x0A>) can be tedious
130and unsightly, as well as confusing to those maintaining the code.  As
131such, the L<C<Socket>|Socket> module supplies the Right Thing for those
132who want it.
133
134    use Socket qw(:DEFAULT :crlf);
135    print $socket "Hi there, client!$CRLF"      # RIGHT
136
137When reading from a socket, remember that the default input record
138separator L<C<$E<sol>>|perlvar/$E<sol>> is C<\n>, but robust socket code
139will recognize as either C<\012> or C<\015\012> as end of line:
140
141    while (<$socket>) {  # NOT ADVISABLE!
142        # ...
143    }
144
145Because both CRLF and LF end in LF, the input record separator can
146be set to LF and any CR stripped later.  Better to write:
147
148    use Socket qw(:DEFAULT :crlf);
149    local($/) = LF;      # not needed if $/ is already \012
150
151    while (<$socket>) {
152        s/$CR?$LF/\n/;   # not sure if socket uses LF or CRLF, OK
153    #   s/\015?\012/\n/; # same thing
154    }
155
156This example is preferred over the previous one--even for Unix
157platforms--because now any C<\015>'s (C<\cM>'s) are stripped out
158(and there was much rejoicing).
159
160Similarly, functions that return text data--such as a function that
161fetches a web page--should sometimes translate newlines before
162returning the data, if they've not yet been translated to the local
163newline representation.  A single line of code will often suffice:
164
165    $data =~ s/\015?\012/\n/g;
166    return $data;
167
168Some of this may be confusing.  Here's a handy reference to the ASCII CR
169and LF characters.  You can print it out and stick it in your wallet.
170
171    LF  eq  \012  eq  \x0A  eq  \cJ  eq  chr(10)  eq  ASCII 10
172    CR  eq  \015  eq  \x0D  eq  \cM  eq  chr(13)  eq  ASCII 13
173
174             | Unix | DOS  | Mac  |
175        ---------------------------
176        \n   |  LF  |  LF  |  CR  |
177        \r   |  CR  |  CR  |  LF  |
178        \n * |  LF  | CRLF |  CR  |
179        \r * |  CR  |  CR  |  LF  |
180        ---------------------------
181        * text-mode STDIO
182
183The Unix column assumes that you are not accessing a serial line
184(like a tty) in canonical mode.  If you are, then CR on input becomes
185"\n", and "\n" on output becomes CRLF.
186
187These are just the most common definitions of C<\n> and C<\r> in Perl.
188There may well be others.  For example, on an EBCDIC implementation
189such as z/OS (OS/390) or OS/400 (using the ILE, the PASE is ASCII-based)
190the above material is similar to "Unix" but the code numbers change:
191
192    LF  eq  \025  eq  \x15  eq  \cU  eq  chr(21)  eq  CP-1047 21
193    LF  eq  \045  eq  \x25  eq           chr(37)  eq  CP-0037 37
194    CR  eq  \015  eq  \x0D  eq  \cM  eq  chr(13)  eq  CP-1047 13
195    CR  eq  \015  eq  \x0D  eq  \cM  eq  chr(13)  eq  CP-0037 13
196
197             | z/OS | OS/400 |
198        ----------------------
199        \n   |  LF  |  LF    |
200        \r   |  CR  |  CR    |
201        \n * |  LF  |  LF    |
202        \r * |  CR  |  CR    |
203        ----------------------
204        * text-mode STDIO
205
206=head2 Numbers endianness and Width
207
208Different CPUs store integers and floating point numbers in different
209orders (called I<endianness>) and widths (32-bit and 64-bit being the
210most common today).  This affects your programs when they attempt to transfer
211numbers in binary format from one CPU architecture to another,
212usually either "live" via network connection, or by storing the
213numbers to secondary storage such as a disk file or tape.
214
215Conflicting storage orders make an utter mess out of the numbers.  If a
216little-endian host (Intel, VAX) stores 0x12345678 (305419896 in
217decimal), a big-endian host (Motorola, Sparc, PA) reads it as
2180x78563412 (2018915346 in decimal).  Alpha and MIPS can be either:
219Digital/Compaq used/uses them in little-endian mode; SGI/Cray uses
220them in big-endian mode.  To avoid this problem in network (socket)
221connections use the L<C<pack>|perlfunc/pack TEMPLATE,LIST> and
222L<C<unpack>|perlfunc/unpack TEMPLATE,EXPR> formats C<n> and C<N>, the
223"network" orders.  These are guaranteed to be portable.
224
225As of Perl 5.10.0, you can also use the C<E<gt>> and C<E<lt>> modifiers
226to force big- or little-endian byte-order.  This is useful if you want
227to store signed integers or 64-bit integers, for example.
228
229You can explore the endianness of your platform by unpacking a
230data structure packed in native format such as:
231
232    print unpack("h*", pack("s2", 1, 2)), "\n";
233    # '10002000' on e.g. Intel x86 or Alpha 21064 in little-endian mode
234    # '00100020' on e.g. Motorola 68040
235
236If you need to distinguish between endian architectures you could use
237either of the variables set like so:
238
239    $is_big_endian   = unpack("h*", pack("s", 1)) =~ /01/;
240    $is_little_endian = unpack("h*", pack("s", 1)) =~ /^1/;
241
242Differing widths can cause truncation even between platforms of equal
243endianness.  The platform of shorter width loses the upper parts of the
244number.  There is no good solution for this problem except to avoid
245transferring or storing raw binary numbers.
246
247One can circumnavigate both these problems in two ways.  Either
248transfer and store numbers always in text format, instead of raw
249binary, or else consider using modules like
250L<C<Data::Dumper>|Data::Dumper> and L<C<Storable>|Storable> (included as
251of Perl 5.8).  Keeping all data as text significantly simplifies matters.
252
253=head2 Files and Filesystems
254
255Most platforms these days structure files in a hierarchical fashion.
256So, it is reasonably safe to assume that all platforms support the
257notion of a "path" to uniquely identify a file on the system.  How
258that path is really written, though, differs considerably.
259
260Although similar, file path specifications differ between Unix,
261Windows, S<Mac OS>, OS/2, VMS, VOS, S<RISC OS>, and probably others.
262Unix, for example, is one of the few OSes that has the elegant idea
263of a single root directory.
264
265DOS, OS/2, VMS, VOS, and Windows can work similarly to Unix with C</>
266as path separator, or in their own idiosyncratic ways (such as having
267several root directories and various "unrooted" device files such NIL:
268and LPT:).
269
270S<Mac OS> 9 and earlier used C<:> as a path separator instead of C</>.
271
272The filesystem may support neither hard links
273(L<C<link>|perlfunc/link OLDFILE,NEWFILE>) nor symbolic links
274(L<C<symlink>|perlfunc/symlink OLDFILE,NEWFILE>,
275L<C<readlink>|perlfunc/readlink EXPR>,
276L<C<lstat>|perlfunc/lstat FILEHANDLE>).
277
278The filesystem may support neither access timestamp nor change
279timestamp (meaning that about the only portable timestamp is the
280modification timestamp), or one second granularity of any timestamps
281(e.g. the FAT filesystem limits the time granularity to two seconds).
282
283The "inode change timestamp" (the L<C<-C>|perlfunc/-X FILEHANDLE>
284filetest) may really be the "creation timestamp" (which it is not in
285Unix).
286
287VOS perl can emulate Unix filenames with C</> as path separator.  The
288native pathname characters greater-than, less-than, number-sign, and
289percent-sign are always accepted.
290
291S<RISC OS> perl can emulate Unix filenames with C</> as path
292separator, or go native and use C<.> for path separator and C<:> to
293signal filesystems and disk names.
294
295Don't assume Unix filesystem access semantics: that read, write,
296and execute are all the permissions there are, and even if they exist,
297that their semantics (for example what do C<r>, C<w>, and C<x> mean on
298a directory) are the Unix ones.  The various Unix/POSIX compatibility
299layers usually try to make interfaces like L<C<chmod>|perlfunc/chmod LIST>
300work, but sometimes there simply is no good mapping.
301
302The L<C<File::Spec>|File::Spec> modules provide methods to manipulate path
303specifications and return the results in native format for each
304platform.  This is often unnecessary as Unix-style paths are
305understood by Perl on every supported platform, but if you need to
306produce native paths for a native utility that does not understand
307Unix syntax, or if you are operating on paths or path components
308in unknown (and thus possibly native) syntax, L<C<File::Spec>|File::Spec>
309is your friend.  Here are two brief examples:
310
311    use File::Spec::Functions;
312    chdir(updir());        # go up one directory
313
314    # Concatenate a path from its components
315    my $file = catfile(updir(), 'temp', 'file.txt');
316    # on Unix:    '../temp/file.txt'
317    # on Win32:   '..\temp\file.txt'
318    # on VMS:     '[-.temp]file.txt'
319
320In general, production code should not have file paths hardcoded.
321Making them user-supplied or read from a configuration file is
322better, keeping in mind that file path syntax varies on different
323machines.
324
325This is especially noticeable in scripts like Makefiles and test suites,
326which often assume C</> as a path separator for subdirectories.
327
328Also of use is L<C<File::Basename>|File::Basename> from the standard
329distribution, which splits a pathname into pieces (base filename, full
330path to directory, and file suffix).
331
332Even when on a single platform (if you can call Unix a single platform),
333remember not to count on the existence or the contents of particular
334system-specific files or directories, like F</etc/passwd>,
335F</etc/sendmail.conf>, F</etc/resolv.conf>, or even F</tmp/>.  For
336example, F</etc/passwd> may exist but not contain the encrypted
337passwords, because the system is using some form of enhanced security.
338Or it may not contain all the accounts, because the system is using NIS.
339If code does need to rely on such a file, include a description of the
340file and its format in the code's documentation, then make it easy for
341the user to override the default location of the file.
342
343Don't assume a text file will end with a newline.  They should,
344but people forget.
345
346Do not have two files or directories of the same name with different
347case, like F<test.pl> and F<Test.pl>, as many platforms have
348case-insensitive (or at least case-forgiving) filenames.  Also, try
349not to have non-word characters (except for C<.>) in the names, and
350keep them to the 8.3 convention, for maximum portability, onerous a
351burden though this may appear.
352
353Likewise, when using the L<C<AutoSplit>|AutoSplit> module, try to keep
354your functions to 8.3 naming and case-insensitive conventions; or, at the
355least, make it so the resulting files have a unique (case-insensitively)
356first 8 characters.
357
358Whitespace in filenames is tolerated on most systems, but not all,
359and even on systems where it might be tolerated, some utilities
360might become confused by such whitespace.
361
362Many systems (DOS, VMS ODS-2) cannot have more than one C<.> in their
363filenames.
364
365Don't assume C<< > >> won't be the first character of a filename.
366Always use the three-arg version of
367L<C<open>|perlfunc/open FILEHANDLE,MODE,EXPR>:
368
369    open my $fh, '<', $existing_file) or die $!;
370
371Two-arg L<C<open>|perlfunc/open FILEHANDLE,MODE,EXPR> is magic and can
372translate characters like C<< > >>, C<< < >>, and C<|> in filenames,
373which is usually the wrong thing to do.
374L<C<sysopen>|perlfunc/sysopen FILEHANDLE,FILENAME,MODE> and three-arg
375L<C<open>|perlfunc/open FILEHANDLE,MODE,EXPR> don't have this problem.
376
377Don't use C<:> as a part of a filename since many systems use that for
378their own semantics (Mac OS Classic for separating pathname components,
379many networking schemes and utilities for separating the nodename and
380the pathname, and so on).  For the same reasons, avoid C<@>, C<;> and
381C<|>.
382
383Don't assume that in pathnames you can collapse two leading slashes
384C<//> into one: some networking and clustering filesystems have special
385semantics for that.  Let the operating system sort it out.
386
387The I<portable filename characters> as defined by ANSI C are
388
389 a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z
390 A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
391 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
392 . _ -
393
394and C<-> shouldn't be the first character.  If you want to be
395hypercorrect, stay case-insensitive and within the 8.3 naming
396convention (all the files and directories have to be unique within one
397directory if their names are lowercased and truncated to eight
398characters before the C<.>, if any, and to three characters after the
399C<.>, if any).  (And do not use C<.>s in directory names.)
400
401=head2 System Interaction
402
403Not all platforms provide a command line.  These are usually platforms
404that rely primarily on a Graphical User Interface (GUI) for user
405interaction.  A program requiring a command line interface might
406not work everywhere.  This is probably for the user of the program
407to deal with, so don't stay up late worrying about it.
408
409Some platforms can't delete or rename files held open by the system,
410this limitation may also apply to changing filesystem metainformation
411like file permissions or owners.  Remember to
412L<C<close>|perlfunc/close FILEHANDLE> files when you are done with them.
413Don't L<C<unlink>|perlfunc/unlink LIST> or
414L<C<rename>|perlfunc/rename OLDNAME,NEWNAME> an open file.  Don't
415L<C<tie>|perlfunc/tie VARIABLE,CLASSNAME,LIST> or
416L<C<open>|perlfunc/open FILEHANDLE,MODE,EXPR> a file already tied or opened;
417L<C<untie>|perlfunc/untie VARIABLE> or
418L<C<close>|perlfunc/close FILEHANDLE> it first.
419
420Don't open the same file more than once at a time for writing, as some
421operating systems put mandatory locks on such files.
422
423Don't assume that write/modify permission on a directory gives the
424right to add or delete files/directories in that directory.  That is
425filesystem specific: in some filesystems you need write/modify
426permission also (or even just) in the file/directory itself.  In some
427filesystems (AFS, DFS) the permission to add/delete directory entries
428is a completely separate permission.
429
430Don't assume that a single L<C<unlink>|perlfunc/unlink LIST> completely
431gets rid of the file: some filesystems (most notably the ones in VMS) have
432versioned filesystems, and L<C<unlink>|perlfunc/unlink LIST> removes only
433the most recent one (it doesn't remove all the versions because by default
434the native tools on those platforms remove just the most recent version,
435too).  The portable idiom to remove all the versions of a file is
436
437    1 while unlink "file";
438
439This will terminate if the file is undeletable for some reason
440(protected, not there, and so on).
441
442Don't count on a specific environment variable existing in
443L<C<%ENV>|perlvar/%ENV>.  Don't count on L<C<%ENV>|perlvar/%ENV> entries
444being case-sensitive, or even case-preserving.  Don't try to clear
445L<C<%ENV>|perlvar/%ENV> by saying C<%ENV = ();>, or, if you really have
446to, make it conditional on C<$^O ne 'VMS'> since in VMS the
447L<C<%ENV>|perlvar/%ENV> table is much more than a per-process key-value
448string table.
449
450On VMS, some entries in the L<C<%ENV>|perlvar/%ENV> hash are dynamically
451created when their key is used on a read if they did not previously
452exist.  The values for C<$ENV{HOME}>, C<$ENV{TERM}>, C<$ENV{PATH}>, and
453C<$ENV{USER}>, are known to be dynamically generated.  The specific names
454that are dynamically generated may vary with the version of the C library
455on VMS, and more may exist than are documented.
456
457On VMS by default, changes to the L<C<%ENV>|perlvar/%ENV> hash persist
458after perl exits.  Subsequent invocations of perl in the same process can
459inadvertently inherit environment settings that were meant to be
460temporary.
461
462Don't count on signals or L<C<%SIG>|perlvar/%SIG> for anything.
463
464Don't count on filename globbing.  Use
465L<C<opendir>|perlfunc/opendir DIRHANDLE,EXPR>,
466L<C<readdir>|perlfunc/readdir DIRHANDLE>, and
467L<C<closedir>|perlfunc/closedir DIRHANDLE> instead.
468
469Don't count on per-program environment variables, or per-program current
470directories.
471
472Don't count on specific values of L<C<$!>|perlvar/$!>, neither numeric nor
473especially the string values. Users may switch their locales causing
474error messages to be translated into their languages.  If you can
475trust a POSIXish environment, you can portably use the symbols defined
476by the L<C<Errno>|Errno> module, like C<ENOENT>.  And don't trust on the
477values of L<C<$!>|perlvar/$!> at all except immediately after a failed
478system call.
479
480=head2 Command names versus file pathnames
481
482Don't assume that the name used to invoke a command or program with
483L<C<system>|perlfunc/system LIST> or L<C<exec>|perlfunc/exec LIST> can
484also be used to test for the existence of the file that holds the
485executable code for that command or program.
486First, many systems have "internal" commands that are built-in to the
487shell or OS and while these commands can be invoked, there is no
488corresponding file.  Second, some operating systems (e.g., Cygwin,
489OS/2, and VOS) have required suffixes for executable files;
490these suffixes are generally permitted on the command name but are not
491required.  Thus, a command like C<perl> might exist in a file named
492F<perl>, F<perl.exe>, or F<perl.pm>, depending on the operating system.
493The variable L<C<$Config{_exe}>|Config/C<_exe>> in the
494L<C<Config>|Config> module holds the executable suffix, if any.  Third,
495the VMS port carefully sets up L<C<$^X>|perlvar/$^X> and
496L<C<$Config{perlpath}>|Config/C<perlpath>> so that no further processing
497is required.  This is just as well, because the matching regular
498expression used below would then have to deal with a possible trailing
499version number in the VMS file name.
500
501To convert L<C<$^X>|perlvar/$^X> to a file pathname, taking account of
502the requirements of the various operating system possibilities, say:
503
504 use Config;
505 my $thisperl = $^X;
506 if ($^O ne 'VMS') {
507     $thisperl .= $Config{_exe}
508         unless $thisperl =~ m/\Q$Config{_exe}\E$/i;
509 }
510
511To convert L<C<$Config{perlpath}>|Config/C<perlpath>> to a file pathname, say:
512
513 use Config;
514 my $thisperl = $Config{perlpath};
515 if ($^O ne 'VMS') {
516     $thisperl .= $Config{_exe}
517         unless $thisperl =~ m/\Q$Config{_exe}\E$/i;
518 }
519
520=head2 Networking
521
522Don't assume that you can reach the public Internet.
523
524Don't assume that there is only one way to get through firewalls
525to the public Internet.
526
527Don't assume that you can reach outside world through any other port
528than 80, or some web proxy.  ftp is blocked by many firewalls.
529
530Don't assume that you can send email by connecting to the local SMTP port.
531
532Don't assume that you can reach yourself or any node by the name
533'localhost'.  The same goes for '127.0.0.1'.  You will have to try both.
534
535Don't assume that the host has only one network card, or that it
536can't bind to many virtual IP addresses.
537
538Don't assume a particular network device name.
539
540Don't assume a particular set of
541L<C<ioctl>|perlfunc/ioctl FILEHANDLE,FUNCTION,SCALAR>s will work.
542
543Don't assume that you can ping hosts and get replies.
544
545Don't assume that any particular port (service) will respond.
546
547Don't assume that L<C<Sys::Hostname>|Sys::Hostname> (or any other API or
548command) returns either a fully qualified hostname or a non-qualified
549hostname: it all depends on how the system had been configured.  Also
550remember that for things such as DHCP and NAT, the hostname you get back
551might not be very useful.
552
553All the above I<don't>s may look daunting, and they are, but the key
554is to degrade gracefully if one cannot reach the particular network
555service one wants.  Croaking or hanging do not look very professional.
556
557=head2 Interprocess Communication (IPC)
558
559In general, don't directly access the system in code meant to be
560portable.  That means, no L<C<system>|perlfunc/system LIST>,
561L<C<exec>|perlfunc/exec LIST>, L<C<fork>|perlfunc/fork>,
562L<C<pipe>|perlfunc/pipe READHANDLE,WRITEHANDLE>,
563L<C<``> or C<qxE<sol>E<sol>>|perlop/C<qxE<sol>I<STRING>E<sol>>>,
564L<C<open>|perlfunc/open FILEHANDLE,MODE,EXPR> with a C<|>, nor any of the other
565things that makes being a Perl hacker worth being.
566
567Commands that launch external processes are generally supported on
568most platforms (though many of them do not support any type of
569forking).  The problem with using them arises from what you invoke
570them on.  External tools are often named differently on different
571platforms, may not be available in the same location, might accept
572different arguments, can behave differently, and often present their
573results in a platform-dependent way.  Thus, you should seldom depend
574on them to produce consistent results.  (Then again, if you're calling
575C<netstat -a>, you probably don't expect it to run on both Unix and CP/M.)
576
577One especially common bit of Perl code is opening a pipe to B<sendmail>:
578
579    open(my $mail, '|-', '/usr/lib/sendmail -t')
580	or die "cannot fork sendmail: $!";
581
582This is fine for systems programming when sendmail is known to be
583available.  But it is not fine for many non-Unix systems, and even
584some Unix systems that may not have sendmail installed.  If a portable
585solution is needed, see the various distributions on CPAN that deal
586with it.  L<C<Mail::Mailer>|Mail::Mailer> and L<C<Mail::Send>|Mail::Send>
587in the C<MailTools> distribution are commonly used, and provide several
588mailing methods, including C<mail>, C<sendmail>, and direct SMTP (via
589L<C<Net::SMTP>|Net::SMTP>) if a mail transfer agent is not available.
590L<C<Mail::Sendmail>|Mail::Sendmail> is a standalone module that provides
591simple, platform-independent mailing.
592
593The Unix System V IPC (C<msg*(), sem*(), shm*()>) is not available
594even on all Unix platforms.
595
596Do not use either the bare result of C<pack("N", 10, 20, 30, 40)> or
597bare v-strings (such as C<v10.20.30.40>) to represent IPv4 addresses:
598both forms just pack the four bytes into network order.  That this
599would be equal to the C language C<in_addr> struct (which is what the
600socket code internally uses) is not guaranteed.  To be portable use
601the routines of the L<C<Socket>|Socket> module, such as
602L<C<inet_aton>|Socket/$ip_address = inet_aton $string>,
603L<C<inet_ntoa>|Socket/$string = inet_ntoa $ip_address>, and
604L<C<sockaddr_in>|Socket/$sockaddr = sockaddr_in $port, $ip_address>.
605
606The rule of thumb for portable code is: Do it all in portable Perl, or
607use a module (that may internally implement it with platform-specific
608code, but exposes a common interface).
609
610=head2 External Subroutines (XS)
611
612XS code can usually be made to work with any platform, but dependent
613libraries, header files, etc., might not be readily available or
614portable, or the XS code itself might be platform-specific, just as Perl
615code might be.  If the libraries and headers are portable, then it is
616normally reasonable to make sure the XS code is portable, too.
617
618A different type of portability issue arises when writing XS code:
619availability of a C compiler on the end-user's system.  C brings
620with it its own portability issues, and writing XS code will expose
621you to some of those.  Writing purely in Perl is an easier way to
622achieve portability.
623
624=head2 Standard Modules
625
626In general, the standard modules work across platforms.  Notable
627exceptions are the L<C<CPAN>|CPAN> module (which currently makes
628connections to external programs that may not be available),
629platform-specific modules (like L<C<ExtUtils::MM_VMS>|ExtUtils::MM_VMS>),
630and DBM modules.
631
632There is no one DBM module available on all platforms.
633L<C<SDBM_File>|SDBM_File> and the others are generally available on all
634Unix and DOSish ports, but not in MacPerl, where only
635L<C<NDBM_File>|NDBM_File> and L<C<DB_File>|DB_File> are available.
636
637The good news is that at least some DBM module should be available, and
638L<C<AnyDBM_File>|AnyDBM_File> will use whichever module it can find.  Of
639course, then the code needs to be fairly strict, dropping to the greatest
640common factor (e.g., not exceeding 1K for each record), so that it will
641work with any DBM module.  See L<AnyDBM_File> for more details.
642
643=head2 Time and Date
644
645The system's notion of time of day and calendar date is controlled in
646widely different ways.  Don't assume the timezone is stored in C<$ENV{TZ}>,
647and even if it is, don't assume that you can control the timezone through
648that variable.  Don't assume anything about the three-letter timezone
649abbreviations (for example that MST would be the Mountain Standard Time,
650it's been known to stand for Moscow Standard Time).  If you need to
651use timezones, express them in some unambiguous format like the
652exact number of minutes offset from UTC, or the POSIX timezone
653format.
654
655Don't assume that the epoch starts at 00:00:00, January 1, 1970,
656because that is OS- and implementation-specific.  It is better to
657store a date in an unambiguous representation.  The ISO 8601 standard
658defines YYYY-MM-DD as the date format, or YYYY-MM-DDTHH:MM:SS
659(that's a literal "T" separating the date from the time).
660Please do use the ISO 8601 instead of making us guess what
661date 02/03/04 might be.  ISO 8601 even sorts nicely as-is.
662A text representation (like "1987-12-18") can be easily converted
663into an OS-specific value using a module like
664L<C<Time::Piece>|Time::Piece> (see L<Time::Piece/Date Parsing>) or
665L<C<Date::Parse>|Date::Parse>.  An array of values, such as those
666returned by L<C<localtime>|perlfunc/localtime EXPR>, can be converted to an OS-specific
667representation using L<C<Time::Local>|Time::Local>.
668
669When calculating specific times, such as for tests in time or date modules,
670it may be appropriate to calculate an offset for the epoch.
671
672    use Time::Local qw(timegm);
673    my $offset = timegm(0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 1970);
674
675The value for C<$offset> in Unix will be C<0>, but in Mac OS Classic
676will be some large number.  C<$offset> can then be added to a Unix time
677value to get what should be the proper value on any system.
678
679=head2 Character sets and character encoding
680
681Assume very little about character sets.
682
683Assume nothing about numerical values (L<C<ord>|perlfunc/ord EXPR>,
684L<C<chr>|perlfunc/chr NUMBER>) of characters.
685Do not use explicit code point ranges (like C<\xHH-\xHH)>.  However,
686starting in Perl v5.22, regular expression pattern bracketed character
687class ranges specified like C<qr/[\N{U+HH}-\N{U+HH}]/> are portable,
688and starting in Perl v5.24, the same ranges are portable in
689L<C<trE<sol>E<sol>E<sol>>|perlop/C<trE<sol>I<SEARCHLIST>E<sol>I<REPLACEMENTLIST>E<sol>cdsr>>.
690You can portably use symbolic character classes like C<[:print:]>.
691
692Do not assume that the alphabetic characters are encoded contiguously
693(in the numeric sense).  There may be gaps.  Special coding in Perl,
694however, guarantees that all subsets of C<qr/[A-Z]/>, C<qr/[a-z]/>, and
695C<qr/[0-9]/> behave as expected.
696L<C<trE<sol>E<sol>E<sol>>|perlop/C<trE<sol>I<SEARCHLIST>E<sol>I<REPLACEMENTLIST>E<sol>cdsr>>
697behaves the same for these ranges.  In patterns, any ranges specified with
698end points using the C<\N{...}> notations ensures character set
699portability, but it is a bug in Perl v5.22 that this isn't true of
700L<C<trE<sol>E<sol>E<sol>>|perlop/C<trE<sol>I<SEARCHLIST>E<sol>I<REPLACEMENTLIST>E<sol>cdsr>>,
701fixed in v5.24.
702
703Do not assume anything about the ordering of the characters.
704The lowercase letters may come before or after the uppercase letters;
705the lowercase and uppercase may be interlaced so that both "a" and "A"
706come before "b"; the accented and other international characters may
707be interlaced so that E<auml> comes before "b".
708L<Unicode::Collate> can be used to sort this all out.
709
710=head2 Internationalisation
711
712If you may assume POSIX (a rather large assumption), you may read
713more about the POSIX locale system from L<perllocale>.  The locale
714system at least attempts to make things a little bit more portable,
715or at least more convenient and native-friendly for non-English
716users.  The system affects character sets and encoding, and date
717and time formatting--amongst other things.
718
719If you really want to be international, you should consider Unicode.
720See L<perluniintro> and L<perlunicode> for more information.
721
722By default Perl assumes your source code is written in an 8-bit ASCII
723superset. To embed Unicode characters in your strings and regexes, you can
724use the L<C<\x{HH}> or (more portably) C<\N{U+HH}>
725notations|perlop/Quote and Quote-like Operators>. You can also use the
726L<C<utf8>|utf8> pragma and write your code in UTF-8, which lets you use
727Unicode characters directly (not just in quoted constructs but also in
728identifiers).
729
730=head2 System Resources
731
732If your code is destined for systems with severely constrained (or
733missing!) virtual memory systems then you want to be I<especially> mindful
734of avoiding wasteful constructs such as:
735
736    my @lines = <$very_large_file>;            # bad
737
738    while (<$fh>) {$file .= $_}                # sometimes bad
739    my $file = join('', <$fh>);                # better
740
741The last two constructs may appear unintuitive to most people.  The
742first repeatedly grows a string, whereas the second allocates a
743large chunk of memory in one go.  On some systems, the second is
744more efficient than the first.
745
746=head2 Security
747
748Most multi-user platforms provide basic levels of security, usually
749implemented at the filesystem level.  Some, however, unfortunately do
750not.  Thus the notion of user id, or "home" directory,
751or even the state of being logged-in, may be unrecognizable on many
752platforms.  If you write programs that are security-conscious, it
753is usually best to know what type of system you will be running
754under so that you can write code explicitly for that platform (or
755class of platforms).
756
757Don't assume the Unix filesystem access semantics: the operating
758system or the filesystem may be using some ACL systems, which are
759richer languages than the usual C<rwx>.  Even if the C<rwx> exist,
760their semantics might be different.
761
762(From the security viewpoint, testing for permissions before attempting to
763do something is silly anyway: if one tries this, there is potential
764for race conditions. Someone or something might change the
765permissions between the permissions check and the actual operation.
766Just try the operation.)
767
768Don't assume the Unix user and group semantics: especially, don't
769expect L<C<< $< >>|perlvar/$E<lt>> and L<C<< $> >>|perlvar/$E<gt>> (or
770L<C<$(>|perlvar/$(> and L<C<$)>|perlvar/$)>) to work for switching
771identities (or memberships).
772
773Don't assume set-uid and set-gid semantics.  (And even if you do,
774think twice: set-uid and set-gid are a known can of security worms.)
775
776=head2 Style
777
778For those times when it is necessary to have platform-specific code,
779consider keeping the platform-specific code in one place, making porting
780to other platforms easier.  Use the L<C<Config>|Config> module and the
781special variable L<C<$^O>|perlvar/$^O> to differentiate platforms, as
782described in L</"PLATFORMS">.
783
784Beware of the "else syndrome":
785
786  if ($^O eq 'MSWin32') {
787    # code that assumes Windows
788  } else {
789    # code that assumes Linux
790  }
791
792The C<else> branch should be used for the really ultimate fallback,
793not for code specific to some platform.
794
795Be careful in the tests you supply with your module or programs.
796Module code may be fully portable, but its tests might not be.  This
797often happens when tests spawn off other processes or call external
798programs to aid in the testing, or when (as noted above) the tests
799assume certain things about the filesystem and paths.  Be careful not
800to depend on a specific output style for errors, such as when checking
801L<C<$!>|perlvar/$!> after a failed system call.  Using
802L<C<$!>|perlvar/$!> for anything else than displaying it as output is
803doubtful (though see the L<C<Errno>|Errno> module for testing reasonably
804portably for error value). Some platforms expect a certain output format,
805and Perl on those platforms may have been adjusted accordingly.  Most
806specifically, don't anchor a regex when testing an error value.
807
808=head1 CPAN Testers
809
810Modules uploaded to CPAN are tested by a variety of volunteers on
811different platforms.  These CPAN testers are notified by mail of each
812new upload, and reply to the list with PASS, FAIL, NA (not applicable to
813this platform), or UNKNOWN (unknown), along with any relevant notations.
814
815The purpose of the testing is twofold: one, to help developers fix any
816problems in their code that crop up because of lack of testing on other
817platforms; two, to provide users with information about whether
818a given module works on a given platform.
819
820Also see:
821
822=over 4
823
824=item *
825
826Mailing list: cpan-testers-discuss@perl.org
827
828=item *
829
830Testing results: L<https://www.cpantesters.org/>
831
832=back
833
834=head1 PLATFORMS
835
836Perl is built with a L<C<$^O>|perlvar/$^O> variable that indicates the
837operating system it was built on.  This was implemented
838to help speed up code that would otherwise have to C<use Config>
839and use the value of L<C<$Config{osname}>|Config/C<osname>>.  Of course,
840to get more detailed information about the system, looking into
841L<C<%Config>|Config/DESCRIPTION> is certainly recommended.
842
843L<C<%Config>|Config/DESCRIPTION> cannot always be trusted, however,
844because it was built at compile time.  If perl was built in one place,
845then transferred elsewhere, some values may be wrong.  The values may
846even have been edited after the fact.
847
848=head2 Unix
849
850Perl works on a bewildering variety of Unix and Unix-like platforms (see
851e.g. most of the files in the F<hints/> directory in the source code kit).
852On most of these systems, the value of L<C<$^O>|perlvar/$^O> (hence
853L<C<$Config{osname}>|Config/C<osname>>, too) is determined either by
854lowercasing and stripping punctuation from the first field of the string
855returned by typing C<uname -a> (or a similar command) at the shell prompt
856or by testing the file system for the presence of uniquely named files
857such as a kernel or header file.  Here, for example, are a few of the
858more popular Unix flavors:
859
860    uname         $^O        $Config{archname}
861    --------------------------------------------
862    AIX           aix        aix
863    BSD/OS        bsdos      i386-bsdos
864    Darwin        darwin     darwin
865    DYNIX/ptx     dynixptx   i386-dynixptx
866    FreeBSD       freebsd    freebsd-i386
867    Haiku         haiku      BePC-haiku
868    Linux         linux      arm-linux
869    Linux         linux      armv5tel-linux
870    Linux         linux      i386-linux
871    Linux         linux      i586-linux
872    Linux         linux      ppc-linux
873    HP-UX         hpux       PA-RISC1.1
874    IRIX          irix       irix
875    Mac OS X      darwin     darwin
876    NeXT 3        next       next-fat
877    NeXT 4        next       OPENSTEP-Mach
878    openbsd       openbsd    i386-openbsd
879    OSF1          dec_osf    alpha-dec_osf
880    reliantunix-n svr4       RM400-svr4
881    SCO_SV        sco_sv     i386-sco_sv
882    SINIX-N       svr4       RM400-svr4
883    sn4609        unicos     CRAY_C90-unicos
884    sn6521        unicosmk   t3e-unicosmk
885    sn9617        unicos     CRAY_J90-unicos
886    SunOS         solaris    sun4-solaris
887    SunOS         solaris    i86pc-solaris
888    SunOS4        sunos      sun4-sunos
889
890Because the value of L<C<$Config{archname}>|Config/C<archname>> may
891depend on the hardware architecture, it can vary more than the value of
892L<C<$^O>|perlvar/$^O>.
893
894=head2 DOS and Derivatives
895
896Perl has long been ported to Intel-style microcomputers running under
897systems like PC-DOS, MS-DOS, OS/2, and most Windows platforms you can
898bring yourself to mention (except for Windows CE, if you count that).
899Users familiar with I<COMMAND.COM> or I<CMD.EXE> style shells should
900be aware that each of these file specifications may have subtle
901differences:
902
903    my $filespec0 = "c:/foo/bar/file.txt";
904    my $filespec1 = "c:\\foo\\bar\\file.txt";
905    my $filespec2 = 'c:\foo\bar\file.txt';
906    my $filespec3 = 'c:\\foo\\bar\\file.txt';
907
908System calls accept either C</> or C<\> as the path separator.
909However, many command-line utilities of DOS vintage treat C</> as
910the option prefix, so may get confused by filenames containing C</>.
911Aside from calling any external programs, C</> will work just fine,
912and probably better, as it is more consistent with popular usage,
913and avoids the problem of remembering what to backwhack and what
914not to.
915
916The DOS FAT filesystem can accommodate only "8.3" style filenames.  Under
917the "case-insensitive, but case-preserving" HPFS (OS/2) and NTFS (NT)
918filesystems you may have to be careful about case returned with functions
919like L<C<readdir>|perlfunc/readdir DIRHANDLE> or used with functions like
920L<C<open>|perlfunc/open FILEHANDLE,MODE,EXPR> or
921L<C<opendir>|perlfunc/opendir DIRHANDLE,EXPR>.
922
923DOS also treats several filenames as special, such as F<AUX>, F<PRN>,
924F<NUL>, F<CON>, F<COM1>, F<LPT1>, F<LPT2>, etc.  Unfortunately, sometimes
925these filenames won't even work if you include an explicit directory
926prefix.  It is best to avoid such filenames, if you want your code to be
927portable to DOS and its derivatives.  It's hard to know what these all
928are, unfortunately.
929
930Users of these operating systems may also wish to make use of
931scripts such as F<pl2bat.bat> to put wrappers around your scripts.
932
933Newline (C<\n>) is translated as C<\015\012> by the I/O system when
934reading from and writing to files (see L</"Newlines">).
935C<binmode($filehandle)> will keep C<\n> translated as C<\012> for that
936filehandle.
937L<C<binmode>|perlfunc/binmode FILEHANDLE> should always be used for code
938that deals with binary data.  That's assuming you realize in advance that
939your data is in binary.  General-purpose programs should often assume
940nothing about their data.
941
942The L<C<$^O>|perlvar/$^O> variable and the
943L<C<$Config{archname}>|Config/C<archname>> values for various DOSish
944perls are as follows:
945
946    OS             $^O       $Config{archname}  ID    Version
947    ---------------------------------------------------------
948    MS-DOS         dos       ?
949    PC-DOS         dos       ?
950    OS/2           os2       ?
951    Windows 3.1    ?         ?                  0     3 01
952    Windows 95     MSWin32   MSWin32-x86        1     4 00
953    Windows 98     MSWin32   MSWin32-x86        1     4 10
954    Windows ME     MSWin32   MSWin32-x86        1     ?
955    Windows NT     MSWin32   MSWin32-x86        2     4 xx
956    Windows NT     MSWin32   MSWin32-ALPHA      2     4 xx
957    Windows NT     MSWin32   MSWin32-ppc        2     4 xx
958    Windows 2000   MSWin32   MSWin32-x86        2     5 00
959    Windows XP     MSWin32   MSWin32-x86        2     5 01
960    Windows 2003   MSWin32   MSWin32-x86        2     5 02
961    Windows Vista  MSWin32   MSWin32-x86        2     6 00
962    Windows 7      MSWin32   MSWin32-x86        2     6 01
963    Windows 7      MSWin32   MSWin32-x64        2     6 01
964    Windows 2008   MSWin32   MSWin32-x86        2     6 01
965    Windows 2008   MSWin32   MSWin32-x64        2     6 01
966    Windows CE     MSWin32   ?                  3
967    Cygwin         cygwin    cygwin
968
969The various MSWin32 Perl's can distinguish the OS they are running on
970via the value of the fifth element of the list returned from
971L<C<Win32::GetOSVersion()>|Win32/Win32::GetOSVersion()>.  For example:
972
973    if ($^O eq 'MSWin32') {
974        my @os_version_info = Win32::GetOSVersion();
975        print +('3.1','95','NT')[$os_version_info[4]],"\n";
976    }
977
978There are also C<Win32::IsWinNT()|Win32/Win32::IsWinNT()>,
979C<Win32::IsWin95()|Win32/Win32::IsWin95()>, and
980L<C<Win32::GetOSName()>|Win32/Win32::GetOSName()>; try
981L<C<perldoc Win32>|Win32>.
982The very portable L<C<POSIX::uname()>|POSIX/C<uname>> will work too:
983
984    c:\> perl -MPOSIX -we "print join '|', uname"
985    Windows NT|moonru|5.0|Build 2195 (Service Pack 2)|x86
986
987Errors set by Winsock functions are now put directly into C<$^E>,
988and the relevant C<WSAE*> error codes are now exported from the
989L<Errno> and L<POSIX> modules for testing this against.
990
991The previous behavior of putting the errors (converted to POSIX-style
992C<E*> error codes since Perl 5.20.0) into C<$!> was buggy due to
993the non-equivalence of like-named Winsock and POSIX error constants,
994a relationship between which has unfortunately been established
995in one way or another since Perl 5.8.0.
996
997The new behavior provides a much more robust solution for checking
998Winsock errors in portable software without accidentally matching
999POSIX tests that were intended for other OSes and may have different
1000meanings for Winsock.
1001
1002The old behavior is currently retained, warts and all, for backwards
1003compatibility, but users are encouraged to change any code that
1004tests C<$!> against C<E*> constants for Winsock errors to instead
1005test C<$^E> against C<WSAE*> constants.  After a suitable deprecation
1006period, which started with Perl 5.24, the old behavior may be
1007removed, leaving C<$!> unchanged after Winsock function calls, to
1008avoid any possible confusion over which error variable to check.
1009
1010Also see:
1011
1012=over 4
1013
1014=item *
1015
1016The EMX environment for DOS, OS/2, etc. emx@iaehv.nl,
1017L<ftp://hobbes.nmsu.edu/pub/os2/dev/emx/>  Also L<perlos2>.
1018
1019=item *
1020
1021Build instructions for Win32 in L<perlwin32>, or under the Cygnus environment
1022in L<perlcygwin>.
1023
1024=item *
1025
1026The C<Win32::*> modules in L<Win32>.
1027
1028=item *
1029
1030The ActiveState Pages, L<https://www.activestate.com/>
1031
1032=item *
1033
1034The Cygwin environment for Win32; F<README.cygwin> (installed
1035as L<perlcygwin>), L<https://www.cygwin.com/>
1036
1037=item *
1038
1039Build instructions for OS/2, L<perlos2>
1040
1041=back
1042
1043=head2 VMS
1044
1045Perl on VMS is discussed in L<perlvms> in the Perl distribution.
1046
1047The official name of VMS as of this writing is OpenVMS.
1048
1049Interacting with Perl from the Digital Command Language (DCL) shell
1050often requires a different set of quotation marks than Unix shells do.
1051For example:
1052
1053    $ perl -e "print ""Hello, world.\n"""
1054    Hello, world.
1055
1056There are several ways to wrap your Perl scripts in DCL F<.COM> files, if
1057you are so inclined.  For example:
1058
1059    $ write sys$output "Hello from DCL!"
1060    $ if p1 .eqs. ""
1061    $ then perl -x 'f$environment("PROCEDURE")
1062    $ else perl -x - 'p1 'p2 'p3 'p4 'p5 'p6 'p7 'p8
1063    $ deck/dollars="__END__"
1064    #!/usr/bin/perl
1065
1066    print "Hello from Perl!\n";
1067
1068    __END__
1069    $ endif
1070
1071Do take care with C<$ ASSIGN/nolog/user SYS$COMMAND: SYS$INPUT> if your
1072Perl-in-DCL script expects to do things like C<< $read = <STDIN>; >>.
1073
1074The VMS operating system has two filesystems, designated by their
1075on-disk structure (ODS) level: ODS-2 and its successor ODS-5.  The
1076initial port of Perl to VMS pre-dates ODS-5, but all current testing and
1077development assumes ODS-5 and its capabilities, including case
1078preservation, extended characters in filespecs, and names up to 8192
1079bytes long.
1080
1081Perl on VMS can accept either VMS- or Unix-style file
1082specifications as in either of the following:
1083
1084    $ perl -ne "print if /perl_setup/i" SYS$LOGIN:LOGIN.COM
1085    $ perl -ne "print if /perl_setup/i" /sys$login/login.com
1086
1087but not a mixture of both as in:
1088
1089    $ perl -ne "print if /perl_setup/i" sys$login:/login.com
1090    Can't open sys$login:/login.com: file specification syntax error
1091
1092In general, the easiest path to portability is always to specify
1093filenames in Unix format unless they will need to be processed by native
1094commands or utilities.  Because of this latter consideration, the
1095L<File::Spec> module by default returns native format specifications
1096regardless of input format.  This default may be reversed so that
1097filenames are always reported in Unix format by specifying the
1098C<DECC$FILENAME_UNIX_REPORT> feature logical in the environment.
1099
1100The file type, or extension, is always present in a VMS-format file
1101specification even if it's zero-length.  This means that, by default,
1102L<C<readdir>|perlfunc/readdir DIRHANDLE> will return a trailing dot on a
1103file with no extension, so where you would see C<"a"> on Unix you'll see
1104C<"a."> on VMS.  However, the trailing dot may be suppressed by enabling
1105the C<DECC$READDIR_DROPDOTNOTYPE> feature in the environment (see the CRTL
1106documentation on feature logical names).
1107
1108What C<\n> represents depends on the type of file opened.  It usually
1109represents C<\012> but it could also be C<\015>, C<\012>, C<\015\012>,
1110C<\000>, C<\040>, or nothing depending on the file organization and
1111record format.  The L<C<VMS::Stdio>|VMS::Stdio> module provides access to
1112the special C<fopen()> requirements of files with unusual attributes on
1113VMS.
1114
1115The value of L<C<$^O>|perlvar/$^O> on OpenVMS is "VMS".  To determine the
1116architecture that you are running on refer to
1117L<C<$Config{archname}>|Config/C<archname>>.
1118
1119On VMS, perl determines the UTC offset from the C<SYS$TIMEZONE_DIFFERENTIAL>
1120logical name.  Although the VMS epoch began at 17-NOV-1858 00:00:00.00,
1121calls to L<C<localtime>|perlfunc/localtime EXPR> are adjusted to count
1122offsets from 01-JAN-1970 00:00:00.00, just like Unix.
1123
1124Also see:
1125
1126=over 4
1127
1128=item *
1129
1130F<README.vms> (installed as F<README_vms>), L<perlvms>
1131
1132=item *
1133
1134vmsperl list, vmsperl-subscribe@perl.org
1135
1136=item *
1137
1138vmsperl on the web, L<http://www.sidhe.org/vmsperl/index.html>
1139
1140=item *
1141
1142VMS Software Inc. web site, L<http://www.vmssoftware.com>
1143
1144=back
1145
1146=head2 VOS
1147
1148Perl on VOS (also known as OpenVOS) is discussed in F<README.vos>
1149in the Perl distribution (installed as L<perlvos>).  Perl on VOS
1150can accept either VOS- or Unix-style file specifications as in
1151either of the following:
1152
1153    $ perl -ne "print if /perl_setup/i" >system>notices
1154    $ perl -ne "print if /perl_setup/i" /system/notices
1155
1156or even a mixture of both as in:
1157
1158    $ perl -ne "print if /perl_setup/i" >system/notices
1159
1160Even though VOS allows the slash character to appear in object
1161names, because the VOS port of Perl interprets it as a pathname
1162delimiting character, VOS files, directories, or links whose
1163names contain a slash character cannot be processed.  Such files
1164must be renamed before they can be processed by Perl.
1165
1166Older releases of VOS (prior to OpenVOS Release 17.0) limit file
1167names to 32 or fewer characters, prohibit file names from
1168starting with a C<-> character, and prohibit file names from
1169containing C< > (space) or any character from the set C<< !#%&'()*;<=>? >>.
1170
1171Newer releases of VOS (OpenVOS Release 17.0 or later) support a
1172feature known as extended names.  On these releases, file names
1173can contain up to 255 characters, are prohibited from starting
1174with a C<-> character, and the set of prohibited characters is
1175reduced to C<< #%*<>? >>.  There are
1176restrictions involving spaces and apostrophes:  these characters
1177must not begin or end a name, nor can they immediately precede or
1178follow a period.  Additionally, a space must not immediately
1179precede another space or hyphen.  Specifically, the following
1180character combinations are prohibited:  space-space,
1181space-hyphen, period-space, space-period, period-apostrophe,
1182apostrophe-period, leading or trailing space, and leading or
1183trailing apostrophe.  Although an extended file name is limited
1184to 255 characters, a path name is still limited to 256
1185characters.
1186
1187The value of L<C<$^O>|perlvar/$^O> on VOS is "vos".  To determine the
1188architecture that you are running on refer to
1189L<C<$Config{archname}>|Config/C<archname>>.
1190
1191Also see:
1192
1193=over 4
1194
1195=item *
1196
1197F<README.vos> (installed as L<perlvos>)
1198
1199=item *
1200
1201The VOS mailing list.
1202
1203There is no specific mailing list for Perl on VOS.  You can contact
1204the Stratus Technologies Customer Assistance Center (CAC) for your
1205region, or you can use the contact information located in the
1206distribution files on the Stratus Anonymous FTP site.
1207
1208=item *
1209
1210Stratus Technologies on the web at L<http://www.stratus.com>
1211
1212=item *
1213
1214VOS Open-Source Software on the web at L<http://ftp.stratus.com/pub/vos/vos.html>
1215
1216=back
1217
1218=head2 EBCDIC Platforms
1219
1220v5.22 core Perl runs on z/OS (formerly OS/390).  Theoretically it could
1221run on the successors of OS/400 on AS/400 minicomputers as well as
1222VM/ESA, and BS2000 for S/390 Mainframes.  Such computers use EBCDIC
1223character sets internally (usually Character Code Set ID 0037 for OS/400
1224and either 1047 or POSIX-BC for S/390 systems).
1225
1226The rest of this section may need updating, but we don't know what it
1227should say.  Please submit comments to
1228L<https://github.com/Perl/perl5/issues>.
1229
1230On the mainframe Perl currently works under the "Unix system
1231services for OS/390" (formerly known as OpenEdition), VM/ESA OpenEdition, or
1232the BS200 POSIX-BC system (BS2000 is supported in Perl 5.6 and greater).
1233See L<perlos390> for details.  Note that for OS/400 there is also a port of
1234Perl 5.8.1/5.10.0 or later to the PASE which is ASCII-based (as opposed to
1235ILE which is EBCDIC-based), see L<perlos400>.
1236
1237As of R2.5 of USS for OS/390 and Version 2.3 of VM/ESA these Unix
1238sub-systems do not support the C<#!> shebang trick for script invocation.
1239Hence, on OS/390 and VM/ESA Perl scripts can be executed with a header
1240similar to the following simple script:
1241
1242    : # use perl
1243        eval 'exec /usr/local/bin/perl -S $0 ${1+"$@"}'
1244            if 0;
1245    #!/usr/local/bin/perl     # just a comment really
1246
1247    print "Hello from perl!\n";
1248
1249OS/390 will support the C<#!> shebang trick in release 2.8 and beyond.
1250Calls to L<C<system>|perlfunc/system LIST> and backticks can use POSIX
1251shell syntax on all S/390 systems.
1252
1253On the AS/400, if PERL5 is in your library list, you may need
1254to wrap your Perl scripts in a CL procedure to invoke them like so:
1255
1256    BEGIN
1257      CALL PGM(PERL5/PERL) PARM('/QOpenSys/hello.pl')
1258    ENDPGM
1259
1260This will invoke the Perl script F<hello.pl> in the root of the
1261QOpenSys file system.  On the AS/400 calls to
1262L<C<system>|perlfunc/system LIST> or backticks must use CL syntax.
1263
1264On these platforms, bear in mind that the EBCDIC character set may have
1265an effect on what happens with some Perl functions (such as
1266L<C<chr>|perlfunc/chr NUMBER>, L<C<pack>|perlfunc/pack TEMPLATE,LIST>,
1267L<C<print>|perlfunc/print FILEHANDLE LIST>,
1268L<C<printf>|perlfunc/printf FILEHANDLE FORMAT, LIST>,
1269L<C<ord>|perlfunc/ord EXPR>, L<C<sort>|perlfunc/sort SUBNAME LIST>,
1270L<C<sprintf>|perlfunc/sprintf FORMAT, LIST>,
1271L<C<unpack>|perlfunc/unpack TEMPLATE,EXPR>), as
1272well as bit-fiddling with ASCII constants using operators like
1273L<C<^>, C<&> and C<|>|perlop/Bitwise String Operators>, not to mention
1274dealing with socket interfaces to ASCII computers (see L</"Newlines">).
1275
1276Fortunately, most web servers for the mainframe will correctly
1277translate the C<\n> in the following statement to its ASCII equivalent
1278(C<\r> is the same under both Unix and z/OS):
1279
1280    print "Content-type: text/html\r\n\r\n";
1281
1282The values of L<C<$^O>|perlvar/$^O> on some of these platforms include:
1283
1284    uname         $^O        $Config{archname}
1285    --------------------------------------------
1286    OS/390        os390      os390
1287    OS400         os400      os400
1288    POSIX-BC      posix-bc   BS2000-posix-bc
1289
1290Some simple tricks for determining if you are running on an EBCDIC
1291platform could include any of the following (perhaps all):
1292
1293    if ("\t" eq "\005")  { print "EBCDIC may be spoken here!\n"; }
1294
1295    if (ord('A') == 193) { print "EBCDIC may be spoken here!\n"; }
1296
1297    if (chr(169) eq 'z') { print "EBCDIC may be spoken here!\n"; }
1298
1299One thing you may not want to rely on is the EBCDIC encoding
1300of punctuation characters since these may differ from code page to code
1301page (and once your module or script is rumoured to work with EBCDIC,
1302folks will want it to work with all EBCDIC character sets).
1303
1304Also see:
1305
1306=over 4
1307
1308=item *
1309
1310L<perlos390>, L<perlos400>, L<perlbs2000>, L<perlebcdic>.
1311
1312=item *
1313
1314The perl-mvs@perl.org list is for discussion of porting issues as well as
1315general usage issues for all EBCDIC Perls.  Send a message body of
1316"subscribe perl-mvs" to majordomo@perl.org.
1317
1318=item *
1319
1320AS/400 Perl information at
1321L<http://as400.rochester.ibm.com/>
1322as well as on CPAN in the F<ports/> directory.
1323
1324=back
1325
1326=head2 Acorn RISC OS
1327
1328Because Acorns use ASCII with newlines (C<\n>) in text files as C<\012> like
1329Unix, and because Unix filename emulation is turned on by default,
1330most simple scripts will probably work "out of the box".  The native
1331filesystem is modular, and individual filesystems are free to be
1332case-sensitive or insensitive, and are usually case-preserving.  Some
1333native filesystems have name length limits, which file and directory
1334names are silently truncated to fit.  Scripts should be aware that the
1335standard filesystem currently has a name length limit of B<10>
1336characters, with up to 77 items in a directory, but other filesystems
1337may not impose such limitations.
1338
1339Native filenames are of the form
1340
1341    Filesystem#Special_Field::DiskName.$.Directory.Directory.File
1342
1343where
1344
1345    Special_Field is not usually present, but may contain . and $ .
1346    Filesystem =~ m|[A-Za-z0-9_]|
1347    DsicName   =~ m|[A-Za-z0-9_/]|
1348    $ represents the root directory
1349    . is the path separator
1350    @ is the current directory (per filesystem but machine global)
1351    ^ is the parent directory
1352    Directory and File =~ m|[^\0- "\.\$\%\&:\@\\^\|\177]+|
1353
1354The default filename translation is roughly C<tr|/.|./|>, swapping dots
1355and slashes.
1356
1357Note that C<"ADFS::HardDisk.$.File" ne 'ADFS::HardDisk.$.File'> and that
1358the second stage of C<$> interpolation in regular expressions will fall
1359foul of the L<C<$.>|perlvar/$.> variable if scripts are not careful.
1360
1361Logical paths specified by system variables containing comma-separated
1362search lists are also allowed; hence C<System:Modules> is a valid
1363filename, and the filesystem will prefix C<Modules> with each section of
1364C<System$Path> until a name is made that points to an object on disk.
1365Writing to a new file C<System:Modules> would be allowed only if
1366C<System$Path> contains a single item list.  The filesystem will also
1367expand system variables in filenames if enclosed in angle brackets, so
1368C<< <System$Dir>.Modules >> would look for the file
1369S<C<$ENV{'System$Dir'} . 'Modules'>>.  The obvious implication of this is
1370that B<fully qualified filenames can start with C<< <> >>> and the
1371three-argument form of L<C<open>|perlfunc/open FILEHANDLE,MODE,EXPR> should
1372always be used.
1373
1374Because C<.> was in use as a directory separator and filenames could not
1375be assumed to be unique after 10 characters, Acorn implemented the C
1376compiler to strip the trailing C<.c> C<.h> C<.s> and C<.o> suffix from
1377filenames specified in source code and store the respective files in
1378subdirectories named after the suffix.  Hence files are translated:
1379
1380    foo.h           h.foo
1381    C:foo.h         C:h.foo        (logical path variable)
1382    sys/os.h        sys.h.os       (C compiler groks Unix-speak)
1383    10charname.c    c.10charname
1384    10charname.o    o.10charname
1385    11charname_.c   c.11charname   (assuming filesystem truncates at 10)
1386
1387The Unix emulation library's translation of filenames to native assumes
1388that this sort of translation is required, and it allows a user-defined list
1389of known suffixes that it will transpose in this fashion.  This may
1390seem transparent, but consider that with these rules F<foo/bar/baz.h>
1391and F<foo/bar/h/baz> both map to F<foo.bar.h.baz>, and that
1392L<C<readdir>|perlfunc/readdir DIRHANDLE> and L<C<glob>|perlfunc/glob EXPR>
1393cannot and do not attempt to emulate the reverse mapping.  Other
1394C<.>'s in filenames are translated to C</>.
1395
1396As implied above, the environment accessed through
1397L<C<%ENV>|perlvar/%ENV> is global, and the convention is that program
1398specific environment variables are of the form C<Program$Name>.
1399Each filesystem maintains a current directory,
1400and the current filesystem's current directory is the B<global> current
1401directory.  Consequently, sociable programs don't change the current
1402directory but rely on full pathnames, and programs (and Makefiles) cannot
1403assume that they can spawn a child process which can change the current
1404directory without affecting its parent (and everyone else for that
1405matter).
1406
1407Because native operating system filehandles are global and are currently
1408allocated down from 255, with 0 being a reserved value, the Unix emulation
1409library emulates Unix filehandles.  Consequently, you can't rely on
1410passing C<STDIN>, C<STDOUT>, or C<STDERR> to your children.
1411
1412The desire of users to express filenames of the form
1413C<< <Foo$Dir>.Bar >> on the command line unquoted causes problems,
1414too: L<C<``>|perlop/C<qxE<sol>I<STRING>E<sol>>> command output capture has
1415to perform a guessing game.  It assumes that a string C<< <[^<>]+\$[^<>]> >>
1416is a reference to an environment variable, whereas anything else involving
1417C<< < >> or C<< > >> is redirection, and generally manages to be 99%
1418right.  Of course, the problem remains that scripts cannot rely on any
1419Unix tools being available, or that any tools found have Unix-like command
1420line arguments.
1421
1422Extensions and XS are, in theory, buildable by anyone using free
1423tools.  In practice, many don't, as users of the Acorn platform are
1424used to binary distributions.  MakeMaker does run, but no available
1425make currently copes with MakeMaker's makefiles; even if and when
1426this should be fixed, the lack of a Unix-like shell will cause
1427problems with makefile rules, especially lines of the form
1428C<cd sdbm && make all>, and anything using quoting.
1429
1430S<"RISC OS"> is the proper name for the operating system, but the value
1431in L<C<$^O>|perlvar/$^O> is "riscos" (because we don't like shouting).
1432
1433=head2 Other perls
1434
1435Perl has been ported to many platforms that do not fit into any of
1436the categories listed above.  Some, such as AmigaOS,
1437QNX, Plan 9, and VOS, have been well-integrated into the standard
1438Perl source code kit.  You may need to see the F<ports/> directory
1439on CPAN for information, and possibly binaries, for the likes of:
1440aos, Atari ST, lynxos, riscos, Novell Netware, Tandem Guardian,
1441I<etc.>  (Yes, we know that some of these OSes may fall under the
1442Unix category, but we are not a standards body.)
1443
1444Some approximate operating system names and their L<C<$^O>|perlvar/$^O>
1445values in the "OTHER" category include:
1446
1447    OS            $^O        $Config{archname}
1448    ------------------------------------------
1449    Amiga DOS     amigaos    m68k-amigos
1450
1451See also:
1452
1453=over 4
1454
1455=item *
1456
1457Amiga, F<README.amiga> (installed as L<perlamiga>).
1458
1459=item  *
1460
1461S<Plan 9>, F<README.plan9>
1462
1463=back
1464
1465=head1 FUNCTION IMPLEMENTATIONS
1466
1467Listed below are functions that are either completely unimplemented
1468or else have been implemented differently on various platforms.
1469Preceding each description will be, in parentheses, a list of
1470platforms that the description applies to.
1471
1472The list may well be incomplete, or even wrong in some places.  When
1473in doubt, consult the platform-specific README files in the Perl
1474source distribution, and any other documentation resources accompanying
1475a given port.
1476
1477Be aware, moreover, that even among Unix-ish systems there are variations.
1478
1479For many functions, you can also query L<C<%Config>|Config/DESCRIPTION>,
1480exported by default from the L<C<Config>|Config> module.  For example, to
1481check whether the platform has the L<C<lstat>|perlfunc/lstat FILEHANDLE>
1482call, check L<C<$Config{d_lstat}>|Config/C<d_lstat>>.  See L<Config> for a
1483full description of available variables.
1484
1485=head2 Alphabetical Listing of Perl Functions
1486
1487=over 8
1488
1489=item -X
1490
1491(Win32)
1492C<-w> only inspects the read-only file attribute (FILE_ATTRIBUTE_READONLY),
1493which determines whether the directory can be deleted, not whether it can
1494be written to. Directories always have read and write access unless denied
1495by discretionary access control lists (DACLs).
1496
1497(VMS)
1498C<-r>, C<-w>, C<-x>, and C<-o> tell whether the file is accessible,
1499which may not reflect UIC-based file protections.
1500
1501(S<RISC OS>)
1502C<-s> by name on an open file will return the space reserved on disk,
1503rather than the current extent.  C<-s> on an open filehandle returns the
1504current size.
1505
1506(Win32, VMS, S<RISC OS>)
1507C<-R>, C<-W>, C<-X>, C<-O> are indistinguishable from C<-r>, C<-w>,
1508C<-x>, C<-o>.
1509
1510(Win32, VMS, S<RISC OS>)
1511C<-g>, C<-k>, C<-l>, C<-u>, C<-A> are not particularly meaningful.
1512
1513(Win32)
1514C<-l> returns true for both symlinks and directory junctions.
1515
1516(VMS, S<RISC OS>)
1517C<-p> is not particularly meaningful.
1518
1519(VMS)
1520C<-d> is true if passed a device spec without an explicit directory.
1521
1522(Win32)
1523C<-x> (or C<-X>) determine if a file ends in one of the executable
1524suffixes.  C<-S> is meaningless.
1525
1526(S<RISC OS>)
1527C<-x> (or C<-X>) determine if a file has an executable file type.
1528
1529=item alarm
1530
1531(Win32)
1532Emulated using timers that must be explicitly polled whenever Perl
1533wants to dispatch "safe signals" and therefore cannot interrupt
1534blocking system calls.
1535
1536=item atan2
1537
1538(Tru64, HP-UX 10.20)
1539Due to issues with various CPUs, math libraries, compilers, and standards,
1540results for C<atan2> may vary depending on any combination of the above.
1541Perl attempts to conform to the Open Group/IEEE standards for the results
1542returned from C<atan2>, but cannot force the issue if the system Perl is
1543run on does not allow it.
1544
1545The current version of the standards for C<atan2> is available at
1546L<http://www.opengroup.org/onlinepubs/009695399/functions/atan2.html>.
1547
1548=item binmode
1549
1550(S<RISC OS>)
1551Meaningless.
1552
1553(VMS)
1554Reopens file and restores pointer; if function fails, underlying
1555filehandle may be closed, or pointer may be in a different position.
1556
1557(Win32)
1558The value returned by L<C<tell>|perlfunc/tell FILEHANDLE> may be affected
1559after the call, and the filehandle may be flushed.
1560
1561=item chdir
1562
1563(Win32)
1564The current directory reported by the system may include any symbolic
1565links specified to chdir().
1566
1567=item chmod
1568
1569(Win32)
1570Only good for changing "owner" read-write access; "group" and "other"
1571bits are meaningless.
1572
1573(S<RISC OS>)
1574Only good for changing "owner" and "other" read-write access.
1575
1576(VOS)
1577Access permissions are mapped onto VOS access-control list changes.
1578
1579(Cygwin)
1580The actual permissions set depend on the value of the C<CYGWIN> variable
1581in the SYSTEM environment settings.
1582
1583(Android)
1584Setting the exec bit on some locations (generally F</sdcard>) will return true
1585but not actually set the bit.
1586
1587(VMS)
1588A mode argument of zero sets permissions to the user's default permission mask
1589rather than disabling all permissions.
1590
1591=item chown
1592
1593(S<Plan 9>, S<RISC OS>)
1594Not implemented.
1595
1596(Win32)
1597Does nothing, but won't fail.
1598
1599(VOS)
1600A little funky, because VOS's notion of ownership is a little funky.
1601
1602=item chroot
1603
1604(Win32, VMS, S<Plan 9>, S<RISC OS>, VOS)
1605Not implemented.
1606
1607=item crypt
1608
1609(Win32)
1610May not be available if library or source was not provided when building
1611perl.
1612
1613(Android)
1614Not implemented.
1615
1616=item dbmclose
1617
1618(VMS, S<Plan 9>, VOS)
1619Not implemented.
1620
1621=item dbmopen
1622
1623(VMS, S<Plan 9>, VOS)
1624Not implemented.
1625
1626=item dump
1627
1628(S<RISC OS>)
1629Not useful.
1630
1631(Cygwin, Win32)
1632Not supported.
1633
1634(VMS)
1635Invokes VMS debugger.
1636
1637=item exec
1638
1639(Win32)
1640C<exec LIST> without the use of indirect object syntax (C<exec PROGRAM LIST>)
1641may fall back to trying the shell if the first C<spawn()> fails.
1642
1643Note that the list form of exec() is emulated since the Win32 API
1644CreateProcess() accepts a simple string rather than an array of
1645command-line arguments.  This may have security implications for your
1646code.
1647
1648(SunOS, Solaris, HP-UX)
1649Does not automatically flush output handles on some platforms.
1650
1651=item exit
1652
1653(VMS)
1654Emulates Unix C<exit> (which considers C<exit 1> to indicate an error) by
1655mapping the C<1> to C<SS$_ABORT> (C<44>).  This behavior may be overridden
1656with the pragma L<C<use vmsish 'exit'>|vmsish/C<vmsish exit>>.  As with
1657the CRTL's C<exit()> function, C<exit 0> is also mapped to an exit status
1658of C<SS$_NORMAL> (C<1>); this mapping cannot be overridden.  Any other
1659argument to C<exit>
1660is used directly as Perl's exit status.  On VMS, unless the future
1661POSIX_EXIT mode is enabled, the exit code should always be a valid
1662VMS exit code and not a generic number.  When the POSIX_EXIT mode is
1663enabled, a generic number will be encoded in a method compatible with
1664the C library _POSIX_EXIT macro so that it can be decoded by other
1665programs, particularly ones written in C, like the GNV package.
1666
1667(Solaris)
1668C<exit> resets file pointers, which is a problem when called
1669from a child process (created by L<C<fork>|perlfunc/fork>) in
1670L<C<BEGIN>|perlmod/BEGIN, UNITCHECK, CHECK, INIT and END>.
1671A workaround is to use L<C<POSIX::_exit>|POSIX/C<_exit>>.
1672
1673    exit unless $Config{archname} =~ /\bsolaris\b/;
1674    require POSIX;
1675    POSIX::_exit(0);
1676
1677=item fcntl
1678
1679(Win32)
1680Not implemented.
1681
1682(VMS)
1683Some functions available based on the version of VMS.
1684
1685=item flock
1686
1687(VMS, S<RISC OS>, VOS)
1688Not implemented.
1689
1690=item fork
1691
1692(AmigaOS, S<RISC OS>, VMS)
1693Not implemented.
1694
1695(Win32)
1696Emulated using multiple interpreters.  See L<perlfork>.
1697
1698(SunOS, Solaris, HP-UX)
1699Does not automatically flush output handles on some platforms.
1700
1701=item getlogin
1702
1703(S<RISC OS>)
1704Not implemented.
1705
1706=item getpgrp
1707
1708(Win32, VMS, S<RISC OS>)
1709Not implemented.
1710
1711=item getppid
1712
1713(Win32, S<RISC OS>)
1714Not implemented.
1715
1716=item getpriority
1717
1718(Win32, VMS, S<RISC OS>, VOS)
1719Not implemented.
1720
1721=item getpwnam
1722
1723(Win32)
1724Not implemented.
1725
1726(S<RISC OS>)
1727Not useful.
1728
1729=item getgrnam
1730
1731(Win32, VMS, S<RISC OS>)
1732Not implemented.
1733
1734=item getnetbyname
1735
1736(Android, Win32, S<Plan 9>)
1737Not implemented.
1738
1739=item getpwuid
1740
1741(Win32)
1742Not implemented.
1743
1744(S<RISC OS>)
1745Not useful.
1746
1747=item getgrgid
1748
1749(Win32, VMS, S<RISC OS>)
1750Not implemented.
1751
1752=item getnetbyaddr
1753
1754(Android, Win32, S<Plan 9>)
1755Not implemented.
1756
1757=item getprotobynumber
1758
1759(Android)
1760Not implemented.
1761
1762=item getpwent
1763
1764(Android, Win32)
1765Not implemented.
1766
1767=item getgrent
1768
1769(Android, Win32, VMS)
1770Not implemented.
1771
1772=item gethostbyname
1773
1774(S<Irix 5>)
1775C<gethostbyname('localhost')> does not work everywhere: you may have
1776to use C<gethostbyname('127.0.0.1')>.
1777
1778=item gethostent
1779
1780(Win32)
1781Not implemented.
1782
1783=item getnetent
1784
1785(Android, Win32, S<Plan 9>)
1786Not implemented.
1787
1788=item getprotoent
1789
1790(Android, Win32, S<Plan 9>)
1791Not implemented.
1792
1793=item getservent
1794
1795(Win32, S<Plan 9>)
1796Not implemented.
1797
1798=item seekdir
1799
1800(Android)
1801Not implemented.
1802
1803=item sethostent
1804
1805(Android, Win32, S<Plan 9>, S<RISC OS>)
1806Not implemented.
1807
1808=item setnetent
1809
1810(Win32, S<Plan 9>, S<RISC OS>)
1811Not implemented.
1812
1813=item setprotoent
1814
1815(Android, Win32, S<Plan 9>, S<RISC OS>)
1816Not implemented.
1817
1818=item setservent
1819
1820(S<Plan 9>, Win32, S<RISC OS>)
1821Not implemented.
1822
1823=item endpwent
1824
1825(Win32)
1826Not implemented.
1827
1828(Android)
1829Either not implemented or a no-op.
1830
1831=item endgrent
1832
1833(Android, S<RISC OS>, VMS, Win32)
1834Not implemented.
1835
1836=item endhostent
1837
1838(Android, Win32)
1839Not implemented.
1840
1841=item endnetent
1842
1843(Android, Win32, S<Plan 9>)
1844Not implemented.
1845
1846=item endprotoent
1847
1848(Android, Win32, S<Plan 9>)
1849Not implemented.
1850
1851=item endservent
1852
1853(S<Plan 9>, Win32)
1854Not implemented.
1855
1856=item getsockopt
1857
1858(S<Plan 9>)
1859Not implemented.
1860
1861=item glob
1862
1863This operator is implemented via the L<C<File::Glob>|File::Glob> extension
1864on most platforms.  See L<File::Glob> for portability information.
1865
1866=item gmtime
1867
1868In theory, C<gmtime> is reliable from -2**63 to 2**63-1.  However,
1869because work-arounds in the implementation use floating point numbers,
1870it will become inaccurate as the time gets larger.  This is a bug and
1871will be fixed in the future.
1872
1873(VOS)
1874Time values are 32-bit quantities.
1875
1876=item ioctl
1877
1878(VMS)
1879Not implemented.
1880
1881(Win32)
1882Available only for socket handles, and it does what the C<ioctlsocket()> call
1883in the Winsock API does.
1884
1885(S<RISC OS>)
1886Available only for socket handles.
1887
1888=item kill
1889
1890(S<RISC OS>)
1891Not implemented, hence not useful for taint checking.
1892
1893(Win32)
1894C<kill> doesn't send a signal to the identified process like it does on
1895Unix platforms.  Instead C<kill($sig, $pid)> terminates the process
1896identified by C<$pid>, and makes it exit immediately with exit status
1897C<$sig>.  As in Unix, if C<$sig> is 0 and the specified process exists, it
1898returns true without actually terminating it.
1899
1900(Win32)
1901C<kill(-9, $pid)> will terminate the process specified by C<$pid> and
1902recursively all child processes owned by it.  This is different from
1903the Unix semantics, where the signal will be delivered to all
1904processes in the same process group as the process specified by
1905C<$pid>.
1906
1907(VMS)
1908A pid of -1 indicating all processes on the system is not currently
1909supported.
1910
1911=item link
1912
1913(S<RISC OS>, VOS)
1914Not implemented.
1915
1916(AmigaOS)
1917Link count not updated because hard links are not quite that hard
1918(They are sort of half-way between hard and soft links).
1919
1920(Win32)
1921Hard links are implemented on Win32 under NTFS only. They are
1922natively supported on Windows 2000 and later.  On Windows NT they
1923are implemented using the Windows POSIX subsystem support and the
1924Perl process will need Administrator or Backup Operator privileges
1925to create hard links.
1926
1927(VMS)
1928Available on 64 bit OpenVMS 8.2 and later.
1929
1930=item localtime
1931
1932C<localtime> has the same range as L</gmtime>, but because time zone
1933rules change, its accuracy for historical and future times may degrade
1934but usually by no more than an hour.
1935
1936=item lstat
1937
1938(S<RISC OS>)
1939Not implemented.
1940
1941(Win32)
1942Treats directory junctions as symlinks.
1943
1944=item msgctl
1945
1946=item msgget
1947
1948=item msgsnd
1949
1950=item msgrcv
1951
1952(Android, Win32, VMS, S<Plan 9>, S<RISC OS>, VOS)
1953Not implemented.
1954
1955=item open
1956
1957(S<RISC OS>)
1958Open modes C<|-> and C<-|> are unsupported.
1959
1960(SunOS, Solaris, HP-UX)
1961Opening a process does not automatically flush output handles on some
1962platforms.
1963
1964(Win32)
1965Both of modes C<|-> and C<-|> are supported, but the list form is
1966emulated since the Win32 API CreateProcess() accepts a simple string
1967rather than an array of arguments.  This may have security
1968implications for your code.
1969
1970=item readlink
1971
1972(VMS, S<RISC OS>)
1973Not implemented.
1974
1975(Win32)
1976readlink() on a directory junction returns the object name, not a
1977simple path.
1978
1979=item rename
1980
1981(Win32)
1982Can't move directories between directories on different logical volumes.
1983
1984=item rewinddir
1985
1986(Win32)
1987Will not cause L<C<readdir>|perlfunc/readdir DIRHANDLE> to re-read the
1988directory stream.  The entries already read before the C<rewinddir> call
1989will just be returned again from a cache buffer.
1990
1991=item select
1992
1993(Win32, VMS)
1994Only implemented on sockets.
1995
1996(S<RISC OS>)
1997Only reliable on sockets.
1998
1999Note that the L<C<select FILEHANDLE>|perlfunc/select FILEHANDLE> form is
2000generally portable.
2001
2002=item semctl
2003
2004=item semget
2005
2006=item semop
2007
2008(Android, Win32, VMS, S<RISC OS>)
2009Not implemented.
2010
2011=item setgrent
2012
2013(Android, VMS, Win32, S<RISC OS>)
2014Not implemented.
2015
2016=item setpgrp
2017
2018(Win32, VMS, S<RISC OS>, VOS)
2019Not implemented.
2020
2021=item setpriority
2022
2023(Win32, VMS, S<RISC OS>, VOS)
2024Not implemented.
2025
2026=item setpwent
2027
2028(Android, Win32, S<RISC OS>)
2029Not implemented.
2030
2031=item setsockopt
2032
2033(S<Plan 9>)
2034Not implemented.
2035
2036=item shmctl
2037
2038=item shmget
2039
2040=item shmread
2041
2042=item shmwrite
2043
2044(Android, Win32, VMS, S<RISC OS>)
2045Not implemented.
2046
2047=item sleep
2048
2049(Win32)
2050Emulated using synchronization functions such that it can be
2051interrupted by L<C<alarm>|perlfunc/alarm SECONDS>, and limited to a
2052maximum of 4294967 seconds, approximately 49 days.
2053
2054=item socketpair
2055
2056(S<RISC OS>)
2057Not implemented.
2058
2059(VMS)
2060Available on 64 bit OpenVMS 8.2 and later.
2061
2062=item stat
2063
2064Platforms that do not have C<rdev>, C<blksize>, or C<blocks> will return
2065these as C<''>, so numeric comparison or manipulation of these fields may
2066cause 'not numeric' warnings.
2067
2068(S<Mac OS X>)
2069C<ctime> not supported on UFS.
2070
2071(Win32)
2072C<ctime> is creation time instead of inode change time.
2073
2074(VMS)
2075C<dev> and C<ino> are not necessarily reliable.
2076
2077(S<RISC OS>)
2078C<mtime>, C<atime> and C<ctime> all return the last modification time.
2079C<dev> and C<ino> are not necessarily reliable.
2080
2081(OS/2)
2082C<dev>, C<rdev>, C<blksize>, and C<blocks> are not available.  C<ino> is not
2083meaningful and will differ between stat calls on the same file.
2084
2085(Cygwin)
2086Some versions of cygwin when doing a C<stat("foo")> and not finding it
2087may then attempt to C<stat("foo.exe")>.
2088
2089=item symlink
2090
2091(S<RISC OS>)
2092Not implemented.
2093
2094(Win32)
2095Requires either elevated permissions or developer mode and a
2096sufficiently recent version of Windows 10. You can check whether the current
2097process has the required privileges using the
2098L<Win32::IsSymlinkCreationAllowed()|Win32/Win32::IsSymlinkCreationAllowed()>
2099function.
2100
2101Since Windows needs to know whether the target is a directory or not when
2102creating the link the target Perl will only create the link as a directory
2103link when the target exists and is a directory.
2104
2105Windows does not recognize forward slashes as path separators in
2106symbolic links.  Hence on Windows, any C</> in the I<OLDFILE>
2107parameter to symlink() are converted to C<\>.  This is reflected in
2108the result returned by readlink(), the C<\> in the result are not
2109converted back to C</>.
2110
2111(VMS)
2112Implemented on 64 bit VMS 8.3.  VMS requires the symbolic link to be in Unix
2113syntax if it is intended to resolve to a valid path.
2114
2115=item syscall
2116
2117(Win32, VMS, S<RISC OS>, VOS)
2118Not implemented.
2119
2120=item sysopen
2121
2122(S<Mac OS>, OS/390)
2123The traditional C<0>, C<1>, and C<2> MODEs are implemented with different
2124numeric values on some systems.  The flags exported by L<C<Fcntl>|Fcntl>
2125(C<O_RDONLY>, C<O_WRONLY>, C<O_RDWR>) should work everywhere though.
2126
2127=item system
2128
2129(Win32)
2130As an optimization, may not call the command shell specified in
2131C<$ENV{PERL5SHELL}>.  C<system(1, @args)> spawns an external
2132process and immediately returns its process designator, without
2133waiting for it to terminate.  Return value may be used subsequently
2134in L<C<wait>|perlfunc/wait> or L<C<waitpid>|perlfunc/waitpid PID,FLAGS>.
2135Failure to C<spawn()> a subprocess is indicated by setting
2136L<C<$?>|perlvar/$?> to C<<< 255 << 8 >>>.  L<C<$?>|perlvar/$?> is set in a
2137way compatible with Unix (i.e. the exit status of the subprocess is
2138obtained by C<<< $? >> 8 >>>, as described in the documentation).
2139
2140Note that the list form of system() is emulated since the Win32 API
2141CreateProcess() accepts a simple string rather than an array of
2142command-line arguments.  This may have security implications for your
2143code.
2144
2145(S<RISC OS>)
2146There is no shell to process metacharacters, and the native standard is
2147to pass a command line terminated by "\n" "\r" or "\0" to the spawned
2148program.  Redirection such as C<< > foo >> is performed (if at all) by
2149the run time library of the spawned program.  C<system LIST> will call
2150the Unix emulation library's L<C<exec>|perlfunc/exec LIST> emulation,
2151which attempts to provide emulation of the stdin, stdout, stderr in force
2152in the parent, provided the child program uses a compatible version of the
2153emulation library.  C<system SCALAR> will call the native command line
2154directly and no such emulation of a child Unix program will occur.
2155Mileage B<will> vary.
2156
2157(Win32)
2158C<system LIST> without the use of indirect object syntax (C<system PROGRAM LIST>)
2159may fall back to trying the shell if the first C<spawn()> fails.
2160
2161(SunOS, Solaris, HP-UX)
2162Does not automatically flush output handles on some platforms.
2163
2164(VMS)
2165As with Win32, C<system(1, @args)> spawns an external process and
2166immediately returns its process designator without waiting for the
2167process to terminate.  In this case the return value may be used subsequently
2168in L<C<wait>|perlfunc/wait> or L<C<waitpid>|perlfunc/waitpid PID,FLAGS>.
2169Otherwise the return value is POSIX-like (shifted up by 8 bits), which only
2170allows room for a made-up value derived from the severity bits of the native
217132-bit condition code (unless overridden by
2172L<C<use vmsish 'status'>|vmsish/C<vmsish status>>).  If the native
2173condition code is one that has a POSIX value encoded, the POSIX value will
2174be decoded to extract the expected exit value.  For more details see
2175L<perlvms/$?>.
2176
2177=item telldir
2178
2179(Android)
2180Not implemented.
2181
2182=item times
2183
2184(Win32)
2185"Cumulative" times will be bogus.  On anything other than Windows NT
2186or Windows 2000, "system" time will be bogus, and "user" time is
2187actually the time returned by the L<C<clock()>|clock(3)> function in the C
2188runtime library.
2189
2190(S<RISC OS>)
2191Not useful.
2192
2193=item truncate
2194
2195(Older versions of VMS)
2196Not implemented.
2197
2198(VOS)
2199Truncation to same-or-shorter lengths only.
2200
2201(Win32)
2202If a FILEHANDLE is supplied, it must be writable and opened in append
2203mode (i.e., use C<<< open(my $fh, '>>', 'filename') >>>
2204or C<sysopen(my $fh, ..., O_APPEND|O_RDWR)>.  If a filename is supplied, it
2205should not be held open elsewhere.
2206
2207=item umask
2208
2209Returns C<undef> where unavailable.
2210
2211(AmigaOS)
2212C<umask> works but the correct permissions are set only when the file
2213is finally closed.
2214
2215=item utime
2216
2217(VMS, S<RISC OS>)
2218Only the modification time is updated.
2219
2220(Win32)
2221May not behave as expected.  Behavior depends on the C runtime
2222library's implementation of L<C<utime()>|utime(2)>, and the filesystem
2223being used.  The FAT filesystem typically does not support an "access
2224time" field, and it may limit timestamps to a granularity of two seconds.
2225
2226=item wait
2227
2228=item waitpid
2229
2230(Win32)
2231Can only be applied to process handles returned for processes spawned
2232using C<system(1, ...)> or pseudo processes created with
2233L<C<fork>|perlfunc/fork>.
2234
2235(S<RISC OS>)
2236Not useful.
2237
2238=back
2239
2240
2241=head1 Supported Platforms
2242
2243The following platforms are known to build Perl 5.12 (as of April 2010,
2244its release date) from the standard source code distribution available
2245at L<http://www.cpan.org/src>
2246
2247=over
2248
2249=item Linux (x86, ARM, IA64)
2250
2251=item HP-UX
2252
2253=item AIX
2254
2255=item Win32
2256
2257=over
2258
2259=item Windows 2000
2260
2261=item Windows XP
2262
2263=item Windows Server 2003
2264
2265=item Windows Vista
2266
2267=item Windows Server 2008
2268
2269=item Windows 7
2270
2271=back
2272
2273=item Cygwin
2274
2275Some tests are known to fail:
2276
2277=over
2278
2279=item *
2280
2281F<ext/XS-APItest/t/call_checker.t> - see
2282L<https://github.com/Perl/perl5/issues/10750>
2283
2284=item *
2285
2286F<dist/I18N-Collate/t/I18N-Collate.t>
2287
2288=item *
2289
2290F<ext/Win32CORE/t/win32core.t> - may fail on recent cygwin installs.
2291
2292=back
2293
2294=item Solaris (x86, SPARC)
2295
2296=item OpenVMS
2297
2298=over
2299
2300=item Alpha (7.2 and later)
2301
2302=item I64 (8.2 and later)
2303
2304=back
2305
2306=item NetBSD
2307
2308=item FreeBSD
2309
2310=item Debian GNU/kFreeBSD
2311
2312=item Haiku
2313
2314=item Irix (6.5. What else?)
2315
2316=item OpenBSD
2317
2318=item Dragonfly BSD
2319
2320=item Midnight BSD
2321
2322=item QNX Neutrino RTOS (6.5.0)
2323
2324=item MirOS BSD
2325
2326=item Stratus OpenVOS (17.0 or later)
2327
2328Caveats:
2329
2330=over
2331
2332=item time_t issues that may or may not be fixed
2333
2334=back
2335
2336=item Stratus VOS / OpenVOS
2337
2338=item AIX
2339
2340=item Android
2341
2342=item FreeMINT
2343
2344Perl now builds with FreeMiNT/Atari. It fails a few tests, that needs
2345some investigation.
2346
2347The FreeMiNT port uses GNU dld for loadable module capabilities. So
2348ensure you have that library installed when building perl.
2349
2350=back
2351
2352=head1 EOL Platforms
2353
2354=head2 (Perl 5.37.1)
2355
2356The following platforms were supported by a previous version of
2357Perl but have been officially removed from Perl's source code
2358as of 5.37.1:
2359
2360=over
2361
2362=item Ultrix
2363
2364=back
2365
2366=head2 (Perl 5.36)
2367
2368The following platforms were supported by a previous version of
2369Perl but have been officially removed from Perl's source code
2370as of 5.36:
2371
2372=over
2373
2374=item NetWare
2375
2376=item DOS/DJGPP
2377
2378=item AT&T UWIN
2379
2380=back
2381
2382=head2 (Perl 5.20)
2383
2384The following platforms were supported by a previous version of
2385Perl but have been officially removed from Perl's source code
2386as of 5.20:
2387
2388=over
2389
2390=item AT&T 3b1
2391
2392=back
2393
2394=head2 (Perl 5.14)
2395
2396The following platforms were supported up to 5.10.  They may still
2397have worked in 5.12, but supporting code has been removed for 5.14:
2398
2399=over
2400
2401=item Windows 95
2402
2403=item Windows 98
2404
2405=item Windows ME
2406
2407=item Windows NT4
2408
2409=back
2410
2411=head2 (Perl 5.12)
2412
2413The following platforms were supported by a previous version of
2414Perl but have been officially removed from Perl's source code
2415as of 5.12:
2416
2417=over
2418
2419=item Atari MiNT
2420
2421=item Apollo Domain/OS
2422
2423=item Apple Mac OS 8/9
2424
2425=item Tenon Machten
2426
2427=back
2428
2429
2430=head1 Supported Platforms (Perl 5.8)
2431
2432As of July 2002 (the Perl release 5.8.0), the following platforms were
2433able to build Perl from the standard source code distribution
2434available at L<http://www.cpan.org/src/>
2435
2436        AIX
2437        BeOS
2438        BSD/OS          (BSDi)
2439        Cygwin
2440        DG/UX
2441        DOS DJGPP       1)
2442        DYNIX/ptx
2443        EPOC R5
2444        FreeBSD
2445        HI-UXMPP        (Hitachi) (5.8.0 worked but we didn't know it)
2446        HP-UX
2447        IRIX
2448        Linux
2449        Mac OS Classic
2450        Mac OS X        (Darwin)
2451        MPE/iX
2452        NetBSD
2453        NetWare
2454        NonStop-UX
2455        ReliantUNIX     (formerly SINIX)
2456        OpenBSD
2457        OpenVMS         (formerly VMS)
2458        Open UNIX       (Unixware) (since Perl 5.8.1/5.9.0)
2459        OS/2
2460        OS/400          (using the PASE) (since Perl 5.8.1/5.9.0)
2461        POSIX-BC        (formerly BS2000)
2462        QNX
2463        Solaris
2464        SunOS 4
2465        SUPER-UX        (NEC)
2466        Tru64 UNIX      (formerly DEC OSF/1, Digital UNIX)
2467        UNICOS
2468        UNICOS/mk
2469        UTS
2470        VOS / OpenVOS
2471        Win95/98/ME/2K/XP 2)
2472        WinCE
2473        z/OS            (formerly OS/390)
2474        VM/ESA
2475
2476        1) in DOS mode either the DOS or OS/2 ports can be used
2477        2) compilers: Borland, MinGW (GCC), VC6
2478
2479The following platforms worked with the previous releases (5.6 and
24805.7), but we did not manage either to fix or to test these in time
2481for the 5.8.0 release.  There is a very good chance that many of these
2482will work fine with the 5.8.0.
2483
2484        BSD/OS
2485        DomainOS
2486        Hurd
2487        LynxOS
2488        MachTen
2489        PowerMAX
2490        SCO SV
2491        SVR4
2492        Unixware
2493        Windows 3.1
2494
2495Known to be broken for 5.8.0 (but 5.6.1 and 5.7.2 can be used):
2496
2497	AmigaOS 3
2498
2499The following platforms have been known to build Perl from source in
2500the past (5.005_03 and earlier), but we haven't been able to verify
2501their status for the current release, either because the
2502hardware/software platforms are rare or because we don't have an
2503active champion on these platforms--or both.  They used to work,
2504though, so go ahead and try compiling them, and let
2505L<https://github.com/Perl/perl5/issues> know
2506of any trouble.
2507
2508        3b1
2509        A/UX
2510        ConvexOS
2511        CX/UX
2512        DC/OSx
2513        DDE SMES
2514        DOS EMX
2515        Dynix
2516        EP/IX
2517        ESIX
2518        FPS
2519        GENIX
2520        Greenhills
2521        ISC
2522        MachTen 68k
2523        MPC
2524        NEWS-OS
2525        NextSTEP
2526        OpenSTEP
2527        Opus
2528        Plan 9
2529        RISC/os
2530        SCO ODT/OSR
2531        Stellar
2532        SVR2
2533        TI1500
2534        TitanOS
2535        Unisys Dynix
2536
2537The following platforms have their own source code distributions and
2538binaries available via L<http://www.cpan.org/ports/>
2539
2540                                Perl release
2541
2542        OS/400 (ILE)            5.005_02
2543        Tandem Guardian         5.004
2544
2545The following platforms have only binaries available via
2546L<http://www.cpan.org/ports/index.html> :
2547
2548                                Perl release
2549
2550        Acorn RISCOS            5.005_02
2551        AOS                     5.002
2552        LynxOS                  5.004_02
2553
2554Although we do suggest that you always build your own Perl from
2555the source code, both for maximal configurability and for security,
2556in case you are in a hurry you can check
2557L<http://www.cpan.org/ports/index.html> for binary distributions.
2558
2559=head1 SEE ALSO
2560
2561L<perlaix>, L<perlamiga>, L<perlbs2000>,
2562L<perlcygwin>,
2563L<perlebcdic>, L<perlfreebsd>, L<perlhurd>, L<perlhpux>, L<perlirix>,
2564L<perlmacosx>,
2565L<perlos2>, L<perlos390>, L<perlos400>,
2566L<perlplan9>, L<perlqnx>, L<perlsolaris>, L<perltru64>,
2567L<perlunicode>, L<perlvms>, L<perlvos>, L<perlwin32>, and L<Win32>.
2568
2569=head1 AUTHORS / CONTRIBUTORS
2570
2571Abigail <abigail@abigail.be>,
2572Charles Bailey <bailey@newman.upenn.edu>,
2573Graham Barr <gbarr@pobox.com>,
2574Tom Christiansen <tchrist@perl.com>,
2575Nicholas Clark <nick@ccl4.org>,
2576Thomas Dorner <Thomas.Dorner@start.de>,
2577Andy Dougherty <doughera@lafayette.edu>,
2578Dominic Dunlop <domo@computer.org>,
2579Neale Ferguson <neale@vma.tabnsw.com.au>,
2580David J. Fiander <davidf@mks.com>,
2581Paul Green <Paul.Green@stratus.com>,
2582M.J.T. Guy <mjtg@cam.ac.uk>,
2583Jarkko Hietaniemi <jhi@iki.fi>,
2584Luther Huffman <lutherh@stratcom.com>,
2585Nick Ing-Simmons <nick@ing-simmons.net>,
2586Andreas J. KE<ouml>nig <a.koenig@mind.de>,
2587Markus Laker <mlaker@contax.co.uk>,
2588Andrew M. Langmead <aml@world.std.com>,
2589Lukas Mai <l.mai@web.de>,
2590Larry Moore <ljmoore@freespace.net>,
2591Paul Moore <Paul.Moore@uk.origin-it.com>,
2592Chris Nandor <pudge@pobox.com>,
2593Matthias Neeracher <neeracher@mac.com>,
2594Philip Newton <pne@cpan.org>,
2595Gary Ng <71564.1743@CompuServe.COM>,
2596Tom Phoenix <rootbeer@teleport.com>,
2597AndrE<eacute> Pirard <A.Pirard@ulg.ac.be>,
2598Peter Prymmer <pvhp@forte.com>,
2599Hugo van der Sanden <hv@crypt0.demon.co.uk>,
2600Gurusamy Sarathy <gsar@activestate.com>,
2601Paul J. Schinder <schinder@pobox.com>,
2602Michael G Schwern <schwern@pobox.com>,
2603Dan Sugalski <dan@sidhe.org>,
2604Nathan Torkington <gnat@frii.com>,
2605John Malmberg <wb8tyw@qsl.net>
2606