xref: /original-bsd/sys/hp300/DOC/TODO.hp300 (revision 27393bdf)
11. Create and use an interrupt stack.
2   Well actually, use the master SP for kernel stacks instead of
3   the interrupt SP.  Right now we use the interrupt stack for
4   everything.  Allows for more accurate accounting of systime.
5   In theory, could also allow for smaller kernel stacks but we
6   only use one page anyway.
7
82. Copy/clear primitives could be tuned.
9   What is best is highly CPU and cache dependent.  One thing to look
10   at are the copyin/copyout primitives.  Rather than looping using
11   MOVS instructions, you could map an entire page at a time and use
12   bcopy, MOVE16, or whatever.  This would lose big on the VAC models
13   however.
14
153. Sendsig/sigreturn are pretty bogus.
16   Currently we can call a signal handler even if an excpetion
17   occurs in the middle of an instruction.  This causes the handler
18   to return right back to the middle of the offending instruction
19   which will most likely lead to another exception/signal.
20   Technically, I feel this is the correct behavior but it requires
21   saving a lot of state on the user's stack, state that we don't
22   really want the user messing with.  Other 68k implementations
23   (e.g. Sun) will delay signals or abort execution of the current
24   instruction to reduce saved state.  Even if we stick with the
25   current philosophy, the code could be cleaned up.
26
274. Ditto for AST and software interrupt emulation.
28   Both are possibly over-elaborate and inefficiently implemented.
29   We could possibly handle them by using an appropriately planted
30   PS trace bit.
31
325. Make use of transparent translation registers on 030/040 MMU.
33   With a little rearranging of the KVA space we could use one to
34   map the entire external IO space [ 600000 - 20000000 ).  Since
35   the translation must be 1-1, this would limit the kernel to 6mb
36   (some would say that is hardly a limit) or divide it into two
37   pieces.  Another promising use would be to map physical memory
38   within the kernel.  This allows a much simpler and more efficient
39   implementation of /dev/mem, pmap_zero_page, pmap_copy_page and
40   possible even kernel-user cross address space copies.  However,
41   it does eat up a significant piece of kernel address space.
42
436. Create a 32-bit timer.
44   Timers 2 and 3 on the MC6840 clock chip can be concatonated together to
45   get a 32-bit countdown timer.  There are at least three uses for this:
46   1. Monitoring the interval timer ("clock") to detect lost "ticks".
47      (Idea from Scott Marovich)
48   2. Implement the DELAY macro properly instead of approximating with
49      the current "while (--count);" loop.  Because of caches, the current
50      method is potentially way off.
51   3. Export as a user-mappable timer for high-precision (4us) timing.
52   Note that by doing this we can no longer use timer 3 as a separate
53   statistics/profiling timer.  Should be able to compile-time (runtime?)
54   select between the two.
55
567. Conditional MMU code sould be restructured.
57   Right now it reflects the evolutionary path of the code: 320/350 MMU
58   was supported and PMMU support was glued on.  The latter can be ifdef'ed
59   out when not needed, but not all of the former (e.g. ``mmutype'' tests).
60   Also, PMMU is made to look like the HP MMU somewhat ham-stringing it.
61   Since HP MMU models are dead, the excess baggage should be there (though
62   it could be argued that they benefit more from the minor performance
63   impact).  MMU code should probably not be ifdef'ed on model type, but
64   rather on more relevant tags (e.g. MMU_HP, MMU_MOTO).
65
668. Redo cache handling.
67   There are way too many routines which are specific to particular
68   cache types.  We should be able to come up with a more coherent
69   scheme (though HP 68k boxes have just about every caching scheme
70   imaginable: internal/external, physical/virtual, writeback/writethrough)
71   See, for example, Wheeler and Bershad in ASPLOS 92.  For more efficient
72   handling of physical caches see also Kessler and Hill in Nov. 92 TOCS.
73
749. Sort the free page list.
75   The DMA hardware on the 300 cannot do scatter/gather IO.  For example,
76   if an 8k system buffer consists of two non-contiguous physical pages
77   it will require two DMA transfers (and hence two interrupts) to do the
78   operation.  It would take only one transfer if they were physically
79   contiguous.  By keeping the free list ordered we could potentially
80   allocate contiguous pages and reduce the number of interrupts.  We can
81   consider doing this since pages in the free list are not reclaimed and
82   thus we don't have to worry about distorting any LRU behavior.
83----
84Mike Hibler
85University of Utah CSS group
86mike@cs.utah.edu
87