1\version "2.16.0" 2 3\header { 4 texidoc ="Broken volta spanners behave correctly at their left edge in all cases." 5 6} 7 8\layout { ragged-right =##t } 9 10%{ 11 12 13I recently discovered that although the following patch seemed to fix 14the original complaint that it causes other problems (the following 15tests were done in 1.3.116. 16 17I have attached a file which has several break-volta interactions. 18 19With the test file and unmodified 1.3.116 I see the following: 20 21Bar 3 - 1st volta spanner centered on first note - prefer it to start 22closer to key signature (can live with this) 23Bar 6 - 1st volta continuation - perfect 24Bar 9 - 2nd volta spanner starts on left edge of key signature - prefer 25it to start right of key signature 26Bar 12 1st volta starts between first two slurred notes in measure - 27this is not acceptable 28Bar 17 like above with hairpin. 29Bar 23 like above (I had expected this to be OK) 30Bar 20 2nd volta continuation perfect 31 32With the test file and 1.3.116 modified as below I see the following: 33 34Bar 3 Perfect 35Bar 6 1st volta continuation starts with staff - oops 36Bar 9 2nd volta starts on papers left margin - OOPS! 37Bar 12 Perfect 38Bar 17 Perfect 39Bar 20 2nd volta continuation starts with staff - oops 40Bar 23 Perfect 41 42%} 43 44voiceB = { 45 \clef bass 46 \set Staff.instrumentName = "Bass" 47 \set Staff.shortInstrumentName = "B" 48 \key f \minor 49 \time 4/4 50 f1 51 \repeat volta 2 52 { 53 f1 \break 54 } 55 \alternative 56 { 57 { 58 f1 f g \break 59 f e d \break 60 } 61 { 62 f1 | 63 } 64 } 65} 66voiceC = { 67 \repeat volta 2 68 { 69 f f 70 \break 71 } 72 \alternative 73 { 74 f 75 { f f } 76 } 77} 78 79voiceD = { 80 \repeat volta 2 81 { 82 f f 83 \break 84 } 85 \alternative 86 { 87 { f 88 } 89 { f f \break f 90 } 91 } 92} 93voiceE = { 94 \repeat volta 2 95 { 96 f f\break 97 } 98 \alternative 99 { 100 { 101 f 102 103 } 104 { 105 f f 106 } 107 } 108} 109 110<< 111 112 113 \new Staff 114 { 115 \voiceB 116 \voiceC 117 \break 118 \voiceD 119 \voiceE 120 } 121 122>> 123 124 125 126